Belarus tests new BUK missile system as a low-key arms race in Eastern Europe gathers momentum
CSTO states express serious concern over terrorist threat in Afghanistan
Armenia refuses to host Eurasian Economic Union summit
COMMENT: Trump 2.0 could be a blessing for Belarus
Russia sentences dual US-Russian citizen to 15 years on espionage charges
Sanctioned Russian cargo ship sinks in Mediterranean after explosion
Slovakia’s Fico in surprise visit to Putin in Moscow
Russian Muslims allowed to have four wives, religious council rules
Russia’s arms exports slump, Kremlin preparing for possible war with Nato
Ukraine invasion was ‘spontaneous’ and unplanned, Putin claims
Bulgaria’s interim PM Glavchev refuses to sign 10-year military support deal with Ukraine
North Korean troops face heavy losses in Russia-Ukraine War as conflict intensifies
Telia willing to sell its Latvian operations back to government if price is right
The EU Council calls for a European geothermal action plan
FDI in Emerging Europe hit by geopolitical uncertainty and German slowdown
IMF: The 2004 EU enlargement was a success story built on deep reform efforts
Czech National Bank keeps interest rates at 4%
Czech EPH signs agreement with Italian Enel to buy its stake in Slovenske Elektrarne
Hungary grants political asylum to fugitive former PiS minister
Hungarian households have joint lowest consumption levels in EU
Polish industrial production disappoints in November as output falls 1.5% y/y
Polish producer price deflation eases further in November
Slovenia sets up emergency alert system after devastating floods
Albania imposes one-year TikTok ban
Athens conditions support for Albania’s EU accession on protection for Greek minority
EU Council says enlargement is a "geo-strategic investment in peace"
BALKAN BLOG: What Grenell’s return means for US diplomacy in the Balkans
International highway tears through Bosnia’s rural heartlands
Russia reaps harvest of chaos in nearby democracies
Croatian Bosqar Invest acquires bakery Mlinar in €100mn deal
TikTok says it has stepped up moderation ahead of Croatian presidential election
Kosovo bans main Serb party from running in general election
Kosovo's population down 12% since 2011
Kosovo’s president slams EU’s “unfair” treatment
Moldova's economy shrinks by 1.9% y/y in Q3
Bureks vs. Big Macs
Serbia faces backlash over controversial foreign agents bill
North Macedonia's central bank lowers key interest rate by 0.25 pp to 5.55%
North Macedonia’s ex-deputy PM Grubi reportedly flees to Kosovo to avoid detention in corruption case
Romania's ruling coalition survives elections
Romanian liberals orchestrated Georgescu campaign funding, investigation reveals
Formation of ruling coalition in Romania faces deadlock as Social Democrats suspend talks
Tens of thousands rally in Belgrade demanding accountability over Novi Sad railway station disaster
Turkey advances Syria engagement with energy plans and refugee return
Turkey, Syria tandem could mean piped Qatari gas for Europe and a supercharged Middle East clean energy transition
PANNIER: Why the Turkmenistan, Iran gas “friendship” is back on
Syrian-Kurdish SDF’s fighters from outside Syria will leave if Turkey agrees ceasefire, says commander
Growing Islamic finance in Central Asia to unlock GCC investment
INTERVIEW: Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank financing Central Asia’s green future
Award seen as Nobel Prize for human rights won by Kabul women’s rights activist and jailed Tajik lawyer
Corruption probe launched into Armenian satellite project
EBRD warns of risks for emerging markets pursuing industrial policies
Several top Armenian officials resign amid political shake-up
Azerbaijan trades barbs with French and US diplomats in online "Twiplomacy"
Azerbaijan’s Aliyev lines up with Russia and Trump, admits Georgia interference
Trial of seven AbzasMedia journalists begins in Baku
COMMENT: Could Iran open new fronts against Israel and Azerbaijan?
PROFILE: Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili
World Bank approves $350mn as Tajikistan bids to fund completion of $6.3bn Rogun mega hydro project
Russia sells stakes in Kazakhstan uranium JVs to China
Freedom Holding Corp brings FIDE world rapid & blitz chess championships to Wall Street
Kyrgyzstan’s President Japarov demotes liberal democracy in favour of a “traditionalist” ideology
Adylbek Kasymaliev appointed new chief of Kyrgyzstan’s cabinet ministers, predecessor dismissed amid tax corruption scandal
Decades-old Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan border dispute could be over
Hit indirectly by sanctions, Mongolia struggles to find workarounds
HESS: Mongolia’s unique success story between rock and a hard place at risk
Mongolia copper-gold discovery hailed for “globally significant” prospects
Tajikistan: Officials announce discovery of major rare earth deposits
Tajikistan: Rogun Dam is a white elephant in the making – report
COP29: Central Asian states losing arable land
Uzbek national arrested in Moscow bombing that killed Russian chemical defence chief Kirillov
Uzbekistan’s Moscow embassy “clarifying” details on man detained after scooter-bomb assassination of Russian general
Russia's budget oil breakeven price world’s second lowest as oil revenues recover
Southeast European countries look to Algeria to diversify energy supplies
Slovenia turns back to Algerian gas after flirtation with Russian supplies
IEA: Access to energy improving worldwide, driven by renewables
The hurricane season in 2024 was weird
Global warming will increase crop yields in Global North, but reduce them in Global South
Hundreds of millions on verge of starvation, billions more undernourished as Climate Crisis droughts take their toll
Global access to energy starts to fall for the first time in a decade, says IEA
Saudi Arabia hosts kingdom's first Africa summit, to boost ties, promote stability
Putin at 2023 Africa-Russia summit: Wiping debts, donating grain and boosting co-operation
EBRD 2023: Bank to expand into the whole of Africa plus Iraq
Botswana throws the diamond industry a lifeline
Nelson Mandela worried about natural diamonds, Leonardo di Caprio defended them, makers of lab-grown stones demonise them
Botswana’s 2,492-carat diamond discovery is golden opportunity to replicate legendary Jonker diamond's global legacy
Kamikaze marketing: how the natural diamond industry could have reacted to the lab-grown threat
Russia’s Rosatom to support nuclear projects across Africa at AEW2024
JPMorgan, Chase and HSBC reportedly unwittingly processed payments for Wagner warlord Prigozhin
Burkina Faso the latest African country to enter nuclear power plant construction talks with Russia
IMF: China’s slowdown will hit sub-Saharan growth
Moscow unlikely to give up Niger toehold as threat of ECOWAS military action looms
Overcoming insecurity to unlock the Central African Republic’s mineral riches
Russia funding war in Ukraine via illegal gold mining in Africa – WGC report
Rain, rain go away
Africa, Asia most people living in extreme poverty
10 African countries to experience world’s fastest population growth to 2100
EM winners and losers from the global green transformation
Russia blocks UN Security Council resolution on Sudan humanitarian crisis
G20 summit wraps up with a joint statement strong on sentiment, but short on specifics
Malaysia seeks BRICS membership
SDS storms fed by sand and dust equal in weight to 350 Great Pyramids of Giza, says UNCCD
Southern Africa has 'enormous' potential for green hydrogen production, study finds
Kazakhstan has no plans to join BRICS, says Astana
Sri Lanka to apply for BRICS membership
How France is losing Africa
Gabon coup attempt after the re-election of President Ali Bongo
Guinea grants final approvals to Rio Tinto for $11.6bn Simandou iron-ore project
Kenya’s untapped mineral wealth holds the promise of economic transformation
US adds 17 Liberian-flagged bulk carriers and oil tankers to Russian sanctions-busting blacklist
Panama and Liberia vying for largest maritime registry
Force majeure at Libya’s Zawiya Refinery threatens exports and oil expansion plans
Russia, facing loss of Syrian base for Africa operations, seen turning to war-torn Sudan or divided Libya
Libya’s mineral riches: unlocking a future beyond oil
Ukraine claims it was behind massacre of Wagner Group mercenaries in Mali
Can Morocco's phosphate wealth put it at the centre of the global battery supply chain?
Hajj aftermath: deaths, disappearances and detentions spark investigations across world
Sri Lanka's LTL Holdings targets African power sector
Russia's nuclear diplomacy binding emerging markets to the Kremlin
Can Niger's military junta seize the country's uranium opportunity?
Disaster season: heat waves sweep the world – in charts and maps
AI will be a major source of GHGs by 2030, says Morgan Stanley
Niger and beyond: Francophone credit delivers coup de grâce
The world has passed peak per capital CO₂ emissions, but overall emissions are still rising
Trump threatens BRICS with tariffs if they dump the dollar
SITREP: Middle East rapidly destabilised by a week of missile strikes
Colombian mercenaries trapped in Sudan’s conflict
Air France diverts Red Sea flights after crew spots 'luminous object'
COMMENT: Tunisia on the brink of collapse
Tunisian President Kais Saied re-elected for second term
WHO declares "global public health emergency" owing to mpox outbreak in Central Africa, new virus strain
Climate crisis-driven global food security deteriorated between 2019 and 2022 and is even affecting the US
South Korea’s won slides as martial law crisis sparks market turmoil
China unveils $71bn swap facility to revitalise flagging economy
Nozomi Energy snaps up major solar portfolio in Japan
Fukushima's forgotten victims as Japan shifts back to nuclear power
Balancing growth and sustainability: Southeast Asia’s energy dilemma
India’s second-largest clean energy company ReNew plans to go private
India's Competition Commission approves major steel industry acquisition
Trump vows to block Nippon Steel's $14bn bid for US Steel
China dismisses Trump's tariff threat, warns of 'no winners' in trade war
Iraq blocks IMDb website over 'immoral content' claims
Display unveils groundbreaking 50% stretchable screen: a game-changer for fashion and mobility
South Korean users flock to YouTube and Instagram as local platforms struggle
Bahrain and Iran to begin talks on normalising relations
Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Kuwait set to offer Russians visa-free entry
Jaw-dropping discovery: 450,000-year-old tooth unearthed in Iran
China's COMAC eyes Saudi Arabia as launchpad for international expansion
Iran lifts bans on WhatsApp and Google Play, promising wider online access
Dollar hits new high in Tehran ahead of international holidays
Israel claims responsibility for Hamas leader Haniyeh's July death in Iran
Iran's former foreign minister proposes new MWADA regional security framework
Trump signals readiness for Iran nuclear talks via Omani channel – Iraqi media
Iraq halts oil exports to Syria amid regional instability
Israel's Mossad chief calls for direct Iran strike after missile hits Tel Aviv
PODCAST: Emerging Global's Mathew Cohen talks with Ruthie Blum
Iran's Supreme Leader rejects claims of regional proxy forces
Qatar-Turkey-Europe gas pipeline ambition could be back on following fall of Assad
As jubilant Syrian refugees in Turkey celebrate Assad downfall, analysts wonder what comes next in power vacuum
Erdogan sets Damascus as final target for “rebels” advancing in Syria
Kuwait greenlights tax deal with Iraq to prevent double taxation
Iran demands 'equal footing' with Kuwaiti and Saudi plans to drill for gas in Gulf
Middle East power grid struggles as demand hits record high
Iraq braces for severe heatwave with temperatures to reach 49C
Iranian ambassador claims US sets conditions on Syrian-Iranian relations
Israeli settlers from extremist sect cross into Lebanon, IDF confirms
How Assad turned Syria into a narco-state
So you want to get on the right side of Donald Trump? Try gift-wrapping a hotel
ANALYSIS: Regional escalation on the table following Israeli strike on Iran
Sea of Oman oil terminal boosts export resilience amid tensions with Israel
Qatar joins regional powers in Damascus diplomatic outreach
COMMENT: A stable Syria could become a major energy hub
Germany ignored multiple warnings by Saudi Arabia before Magdeburg attack
Saudi Arabia extracts lithium from oilfield runoff, plans commercial pilot
Christmas tree set on fire in Syrian city by masked gunmen
ISTANBUL BLOG: After “conquering” Damascus, Erdogan turns his eye to the Kurds
Israel launches biggest strike in Yemen, killing 40 people
TEHRAN BLOG: Pezeshkian's dilemma over Haniyeh's assassination
Iranian foreign ministry condemns Haniyeh's assassination in Tehran
Reactions to the killing of Haniyeh in Tehran
Argentina announces ambitious nuclear programme linked to AI development
Latin America set for tepid growth as Trump tariff threat looms, ECLAC says
Latin America urged to boost tax take and private investment to close development gap
IMF: Breaking Latin America’s cycle of low growth and violence
COMMENT: Trump’s White House picks signal rocky start with Latin America
Latin America trapped in low growth cycle, ECLAC warns
Bolivian ex-president Evo Morales faces formal charges of human trafficking
Geothermal energy poised for major global expansion, says IEA chief Fatih Birol
US-Cuba rum war spills over as Biden law stirs Havana Club row
Brutal gang violence over failed voodoo spell claims nearly 200 lives in Haiti's capital
Mexican cartel boss who created fearsome Zetas returns to face justice after US deportation
Paraguay stands firm with Taiwan amid growing Chinese pressure
Murder exposes secret prostitution ring in Peruvian Congress
Protests in Bangladesh escalate, demanding president leave office
Bangladesh tribunal issues arrest warrant against ousted PM Sheikh Hasina
World Bank says Bangladesh GDP growth to shrink in FY25
US imposes preliminary duties on Southeast Asian solar imports
COMMENT: From Globalisation to “slowbalisation” as FDIs decline on trade and geopolitical woes
Angkor Archaeological Park attracts nearly 700,000 foreign tourists in nine months
Asia’s shipbuilding renaissance: record orders and rising prices
Almost two-thirds of Malaysians favourable towards China
Blinken warns Taiwan crisis could trigger global economic turmoil
Peru's APEC summit exposes trade tug-of-war between Beijing and Washington
Rising gold ETF inflows set to drive global bullion prices
Russian exports of diamonds to Hong Kong up 18-fold in 5M24
Gazli Gas responds to reports on Uzbekistan project, refutes any suggestion sanctioned individuals are involved
Valuation questions raised over Blackstone's $2.1bn IPO of India’s International Gemmologist Institute
Where does nuclear power-use stand in post-COP29 Asia?
Boldly brewing where no one has brewed before: Japanese sake to be made in space
BCPG to invest $945mn in power projects, prioritising clean energy
Malaysia’s industrial growth slows in October following mixed sector performance
Myanmar junta to allow observers for controversial 2025 election amid ongoing conflict
Nepal floods - death toll rises to 209
Kolkata hospital rape and murder case sparks international outcry, raises questions
South Asia hit by floods and landslides after heavy rainfall
Russian pivot to the Global South includes unscrupulous army recruiting practices
North Korea’s missile support to Russia raises alarms at UN
North Korean troops suffer casualties in Ukraine conflict
South Korea intensifies military drills to bolster defences against North Korean drone threat
Security personnel dead as Imran Khan’s supporters breach Islamabad lockdown
Pakistan could quit TAPI as India now “extremely lukewarm” on gas pipeline project, says report
Papua New Guinea tribal conflict leaves 30 dead amid gold mine dispute
South Korea's acting president rejects six controversial bills amid growing tensions
Korean won dips to crisis levels amid US rate cuts and market volatility
Sri Lanka’s merchandise exports in October up 18.22%
Taiwan boosts defence with advanced Abrams tanks amid rising Chinese tensions
Japan plans tax hike to fund $280bn military buildup
German Prosecutors Confirm Termination of Money Laundering Investigation Against Alisher Usmanov
Comments by President of the Russian Fertilizers Producers Association Andrey Guryev on bilateral meeting between Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin
PhosAgro/UNESCO/IUPAC green chemistry research grants awarded for the 8th time to world's best young scientists
PhosAgro Tops RAEX ESG Ranking
Download the pdf version
Try PRO
Ben Aris in Berlin -
This is the first in a series of pieces over the coming months where bne will look at the structure of ZAO Kremlin.
Got a couple of billion to invest and want some geopolitical clout to go with stellar returns? Buy into ZAO Kremlin - now Russia's biggest industrial holding.
Russian President Vladimir Putin has taken a leaf out of the oligarchs' book and, instead of hounding them into exile, he has joined forces with the richest to create the world's largest corporate structure. ZAO Kremlin is like the financial-industrial groups that the oligarchs have created, but on a much bigger scale. And as a government, it adds a military component to the mix that Putin hopes will make Russia one of the most powerful countries on earth.
ZAO Kremlin controls assets in oil, gas, power, shipping, rail, media, utilities and automotive assets to name a few. Just the publicly listed part of this holding was worth $360bn at the end of last year, or equivalent to 40% of GDP. At their peak, Russia's top-20 oligarchs between them never controlled more than 22% of the economy, according to a World Bank study.
The only trouble is that not just anyone can invest in this corporate powerhouse. That's what ZAO means: "closed joint stock company." Shares can only be sold with the consent of the owners, so you have to be invited into the company.
The divide between politics and business is axiomatic in the West. In Soviet Russia there was no distinction at all. What Putin is trying to do is to build a hybrid system where the state retains control but businessmen both domestic and foreign are invited in and given enough autonomy to make sure that ZAO Kremlin is profitable.
All the national champions that make up ZAO Kremlin's subsidiaries are going to be floated on stock markets to raise investment capital, but more importantly IPOs will bring in people with the commercial nous and management skills to make the companies profitable.
If there is a choice, the Kremlin prefers to work with Russian investors the oligarchs but if the sector is technologically demanding, or the market global, then foreign investors will do. Just as long as control of the company is not given away in the process.
Corporate restructuring and guns
The creation of ZAO Kremlin is a work in progress. Ironically, the Kremlin is going through exactly the same process as the oligarchs went through over the last five years, making liberal use of complicated holding structures, buying assets through empty offshore shell companies and offering investors the most opaque of accounts. Investors hope the Kremlin will continue to follow the oligarchs' example and after the redistribution of assets going on at the moment is completed, the holdings will become more transparent. But the jury is still out on that.
The structure is certainly still very messy. The subdivisions of ZAO Kremlin can be split into three main parts. First are the classic state-owned companies like Gazprom and Sberbank, which are formally controlled by the Kremlin. Then there are the new national champions like United Aviation Company, holding companies that group diverse assets in a single sector, convert them into joint stock companies and provide a vehicle that can be floated on stock markets later to raise investment capital. Finally, there is Rosoboronexport, the state-owned arms export company, headed by Sergei Chemezov. In addition to its arms sale duties, Rosoboronexport has become a corporate holding for Kremlin-backed investments and takeovers.
Chemezov is part of a team of ZAO Kremlin executives who are remaking the economy. Also on the board of directors are Alexei Miller (Gazprom), Igor Sechin (Rosneft), Anatoly Chubais (electricity), Vladimir Yakunin (railways) and Sergei Kirienko (nuclear).
Their approaches to restructuring might be very different and some are more liberal than others, but they share Putin's stated goal of restoring "Russia's place in the sun" by corporatising their sectors, establishing the state's control and raising investment capital.
If there is an ideology shared by this assortment of foreign intelligence officers and liberal economists, it is this: Russia's current economic growth is dangerously dependent on high oil prices. Diversification from commodity extraction into industries and services where added value is generated in Russia is thus not only an economic, but also a national security, imperative.
And like the oligarchs, ZAO Kremlin's control over companies is backed by guns. With an entire army at its disposal, rather than ordinary business' legion of hit men, any fight between an oligarch and the Kremlin is one-sided, but the choice of Rosoboronexport as ZAO Kremlin's holding company of choice is pertinent.
The Kremlin has been using its control over the military-industrial complex as a seed crystal for the growth of the industrial sectors. This is the main difference between ZAO Kremlin and the oligarch empires of the 1990s - Putin has added "military" to the end of the traditional financial-industrial structure.
It is no accident that while many of ZAO Kremlin's national champions are nominally producing products for civilian use, a point that is usually missed is that almost all of these enterprises has a military wing.
While the government plans to invest $118bn into desperately needed power stations over the next five years, it will spend almost twice as much on equipping the Russian army in the same period. At the sovereign level, business is almost as rough as that between competing oligarchs and the Kremlin believes it can't compete on the international stage without a strong conventional army. The US' decision to put missiles in Poland has only reinforced this belief.
Putin has already tied arms sales together with economic development. Since becoming president, Putin has become Russia's best arms salesman. Rosoboronexport's sales have doubled during his tenure to about $6bn a year.
When cutting deals with the likes of Kazakhstan, Venezuela and Algeria, Putin has expanded the idea of energy security in recent oil and gas deals with these countries into overall "security;" arms deals now go hand in hand with the building gas pipelines or developing oil fields.
The Silo-garchs
The first thing Putin did after taking office in 2000 was to build up the presidential apparat into the real seat of political power in Russia, despite it only being mentioned in passing in the constitution. Over the last two years, Putin has been busy with his trowel again, this time building up a corporate apparat that is increasingly becoming the seat of economic power.
This is where the blurring of the line between business and politics comes in. Rather than recreate the monopolistic state-owned companies that were the death of the Soviet Union, Putin hopes to avoid the pitfalls of central planning by bringing in Kremlin-friendly businessmen to manage big chunks of ZAO Kremlin. Putin's Russia is the Soviet Union, except it is no longer evil to make money.
Russia is almost unique in that senior government officers now sit on the boards of the majority of Russia's biggest companies, giving the state formal control over the state-owned enterprises. However, a new class of oligarch has emerged that is close to the Kremlin and under the control of the Siloviki - a Kremlin clique with its roots in the security services. These "Silo-garchs" meet regularly with Putin in one-on-one meetings like managers meeting with a CEO, giving the Kremlin informal, but effective, control over their companies.
With the example of Yukos' bankruptcy still fresh in everyone's mind (and the state's recent takeover of Russneft even fresher), none of the oligarchs are going to resist the Kremlin's advances.
Primus inter pares is Oleg Deripaska, the new "Minister of Acquisitions," who created an aluminium national champion following the merger between his Russian Aluminium and Viktor Vekselberg's SUAL earlier this year. He sat shoulder-to-shoulder with Putin during Russia's successful bid for the 2014 Winter Olympics in July, promising to put $2bn of his own money into the development pot. And his decisions to invest in things like power and infrastructure in recent years are moving in lock step with the Kremlin's own plans to develop the economy.
The Silo-garchs support of the state's goals is not charity; nor have they necessarily been coerced into support. It can be very good business. Deripaska's plans to invest a couple of billion dollars into a new hydroelectric power station next to his Boguchansky smelter was backed earlier this year by over $1bn from the new State Investment Fund the first big allocation the fund has taken on.
Likewise, Putin pressured the Turkish government to allow Alfa Group to acquire a stake in the country's largest mobile phone company Turkcell in 2005, publicly endorsing the deal when it went through. Later, Putin again opened discussions with the Vietnamese government on the possibility of Alfa acquiring a mobile phone company there.
Alfa has also gone into a joint venture with Rosoboronexport called Patriot Capital, where Alfa Bank's staff work their financial and restructuring magic on Rosoboronexport's defence assets.
Some unlikely business leaders have also become Silo-garchs. The owner of investment bank Troika Dialog, Ruben Vardanian, has been working closely with Rosoboronexport Chairman Chemezov. Vardanian now sits on the board of several Rosoboronexport-controlled enterprises such as Sukhoi Civil Aviation, which is spearheading the Kremlin-backed project to create a new passenger plane, and Russpetsstal, a specialist steel producer with military applications which is being set up by the Siloviki .
Other oligarchs have found themselves on the outside. When Renova boss Viktor Vekselberg tried to float his aluminium company SUAL on the London stock exchange last year he was called into the Kremlin and told by Putin "no."
"Vekselberg had almost given up and announced that SUAL would IPO on the London Stock Exchange. But when he met with the president, Putin vetoed the IPO until the merger with RusAl was completed," says a senior executive involved in the talks who didn't wish to be named.
Will it work?
"Putin's Russia is like a dinosaur. It has a tiny brain and it takes an enormously long time for messages to run down the neck to the legs and back again. Once you start it moving it will be very difficult to make it change direction," says Dmitri Trenin from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
The reason why business and politics are divided in the West is because mixing the two is, at best, inefficient and, at worst, an invitation for corruption. But Putin is hoping the disadvantages of state involvement will be outweighed by the advantages that Russia's leading companies will have from the full weight of the Kremlin's backing in their international dealings. At the same time, the plan to privatise nearly all the national champions is supposed to ensure these companies stay commercially minded.
Certainly, as the Russian state is now the biggest shareholder in the country, it can no long afford to scare portfolio investors with politically motivated attacks on publicly traded companies or at least it can't afford to do this too often.
Macroeconomic stability, based on lashings of oil and gas money, and coupled with Finance Minister Alexei Kudrins canny policies, has changed the equation for state holdings: large companies now enjoy direct access to international capital markets and stock exchanges. Capital constraints have been lifted.
Gigantic and secretive entities like the Ministry of Rail and the Ministry of Atomic Energy have transformed themselves into equally gigantic, but potentially less opaque and more efficient, joint-stock companies 100% state-owned, of course.
At the other end of the scale, the ongoing overhaul of the defence industry will see scores of federal unitary enterprises (FGUPs), currently languishing in the orphanage of the federal property fund, corporatised for adoption by national defence concerns. The Federal Agency for State Property has declared its goal to be the liquidation of FGUPs as a class.
And then there's the questions of what role the retiring Putin will have in all this. It doesn't matter if Putin leaves to become the CEO of Gazprom or takes charge of a beefed-up Security Council, in reality he will join some kind of ZAO Kremlin supervisory board and steer the ship from behind the scenes as chairman while a new CEO takes on the day-to-day work. The structure he has created is flexible and he can carve out a position to suit him.
The risks are obvious: will the Kremlin respect inconvenient property rights when setting up national champions? Or will it happily undermine the rule of law, which has, far more than Kremlin policy, been behind the surge in investment rates?
Oleg Deripaska did little to reassure private owners when he declared himself ready to surrender RusAl "if the Kremlin says it is necessary" in July. But showing his loyalty and willingness to give up his businesses if he is told to is probably the best way to ensure that he will get to hang onto them.
Send comments to The Editor
Jason Corcoran in Moscow - Russian banks are disappearing at the fastest rate ever as the country's deepening recession makes it easier for the central bank to expose money laundering, dodgy lending ... more
bne IntelliNews - The Kremlin supported by national sports authorities has brushed aside "groundless" allegations of a mass doping scam involving Russian athletes after the World Anti-Doping Agency ... more
Jason Corcoran in Moscow - Revelations and mysticism may have been the stock-in-trade of Nikolai Tsvetkov’s management style, but ultimately they didn’t help him to hold on to his ... more
Register here to continue reading this article and 8 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Google Captcha Failed!
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription