North Korea rejects Belarus summit proposal, calls for clarity in relations
Belarusian blogger sets up a parody bank and token as a joke and unexpectedly becomes a millionaire
NEO: Why pick-up points for online orders are gaining popularity vs. home delivery
First sighting of Belarusian jailed opposition leader Viktor Babariko in two years
Saving the Caspian Sea for Central Asia and Kazakhstan
Putin congratulates Trump, signals hope for improved US-Russia relations
The World Reacts to Trump 2.0
Antidepressant sales in Russia hit record high amidst growing war stress
The Bavarian branch of far-right AfD party calls for all Ukrainian refugees to be expelled from Germany
War in Ukraine started as punishment for masturbation, says Russian Orthodox Church
Russia reports successful strikes against critical Ukrainian gas and energy infrastructure
COMMENT: With Trump back in the White House, Europe may need to turn to Turkey to strengthen its security
Love in the Baltics in a time of war
Emerging Europe split between eager anticipation and wary acceptance ahead of Trump inauguration
airBaltic CEO and IPO under pressure after flight cancellations
COMMENT: The EU’s Green Deal is a “policy disaster”
Spike in Czech beer exports to Russia highlights cracks in Moscow-bound trade and businesses
Czechia wraps up work on pipeline expansion to end reliance on Russian oil
Czech industry falls by 2.7% y/y in November in another disappointing performance
Analysts ponder why Viktor Orban is skipping Donald Trump’s inauguration
China's Xinzhi creates 900 jobs with €120mn investment in Hungary
Polish central bank NBP turns up hawkish message as it holds rates at 5.75% again
Polish President Duda says Ukraine should join Nato as soon as possible
Slovakia’s populist PM Fico faces no-confidence motion
Slovakia’s Fico steps up anti-Ukraine rhetoric over gas cut-off
Absent Slovak premier traced to luxury hotel in Vietnam
OUTLOOK Southeastern Europe 2025
The EU Council calls for a European geothermal action plan
Sanctions stepped up in the Western Balkans, but with mixed results
Albania, Italy and UAE to build €1bn Adriatic subsea cable
BALKAN BLOG: Trump’s annexation remarks risk reigniting Balkan border disputes
Bulgaria’s new cabinet slammed as ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ by opponents
Croatian deputy PM resigns after video shows him firing pistol from car
Dispute with Croatia over Jadran training ship could block Montenegro’s EU entry
Kosovo shuts down Serbian parallel institutions, escalating tensions with Belgrade ahead of elections
Moldovagaz’s head says $709mn debt to Gazprom close to being settled
Leader of Moldova’s separatist Transnistria flies to Moscow to settle energy crisis
Russian presidential adviser warns Moldova may “cease to exist”
EBRD aims to ramp up investment in Romania to €1bn a year
Poll reveals dominance of far-right presidential candidates in Romania
Mass protests in Serbia test ruling party's grip on power
Serbian financial sector inflation expectations decline in December
Syria says staging grounds for attacks on Turkey will be thing of the past
Number of Turkish energy M&As edges up to 30 in 2024
ISTANBUL BLOG: “Dog bites man” story as Erdogan arrests more mayors, but there’s more here than meets the eye
PANNIER: Tajikistan, Taliban tone down the hostile rhetoric
Central Asia emerges as new e-commerce hub
Growing Islamic finance in Central Asia to unlock GCC investment
CSTO states express serious concern over terrorist threat in Afghanistan
New US strategic partnership could be revolutionary for Armenia
COMMENT: Armenia makes a strategic turn from Russia towards the West
Armenian prime minister discusses EU membership plans with European Council president
OUTLOOK: Caucasus 2025
Fatal road accident triggers widespread protests in Azerbaijan
Gas exports to Europe to boost Azerbaijan's growth over next decade
Georgians celebrate US friendship in Tbilisi while former president Zourabichvili attends Trump inauguration
Two abducted in central Tbilisi following ‘anti-mask law’ protest
Thousands of Georgians walk out of work in three-hour "warning" strike
Georgians still resisting: the view from Rustaveli
Kazakh central bank’s dollar sales to mirror gold purchases
EBRD delivers 26% expansion in investments in 2024, commits record €16.6bn across economies
Central Asian leaders look to expand mutual trade
China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan railway officially launched, but sidetracked at least until summer
Angry Mongolians take to streets in public backlash over taxes and smog
Mongolia revives traditional "Ghengis Khan" script bichig
Smog back with a vengeance in Ulaanbaatar
Iran, Tajikistan sign 23 cooperation agreements in landmark visit
A tale of two Tajikistans: the macro and micro realities
PANNIER: Why the Turkmenistan, Iran gas “friendship” is back on
Football talent Khusanov poised to become first Uzbek to play in English Premier League after Man City signing
Uzbekistan privatises HUMO, Paynet succeeds with $65mn bid
Sanctioned Russian cargo ship sinks in Mediterranean after explosion
Russia's budget oil breakeven price world’s second lowest as oil revenues recover
Southeast European countries look to Algeria to diversify energy supplies
Slovenia turns back to Algerian gas after flirtation with Russian supplies
IEA: Access to energy improving worldwide, driven by renewables
The hurricane season in 2024 was weird
Global warming will increase crop yields in Global North, but reduce them in Global South
Hundreds of millions on verge of starvation, billions more undernourished as Climate Crisis droughts take their toll
Global access to energy starts to fall for the first time in a decade, says IEA
Saudi Arabia hosts kingdom's first Africa summit, to boost ties, promote stability
Putin at 2023 Africa-Russia summit: Wiping debts, donating grain and boosting co-operation
Botswana throws the diamond industry a lifeline
Nelson Mandela worried about natural diamonds, Leonardo di Caprio defended them, makers of lab-grown stones demonise them
Botswana’s 2,492-carat diamond discovery is golden opportunity to replicate legendary Jonker diamond's global legacy
Kamikaze marketing: how the natural diamond industry could have reacted to the lab-grown threat
Russia’s Rosatom to support nuclear projects across Africa at AEW2024
JPMorgan, Chase and HSBC reportedly unwittingly processed payments for Wagner warlord Prigozhin
Burkina Faso the latest African country to enter nuclear power plant construction talks with Russia
IMF: China’s slowdown will hit sub-Saharan growth
Moscow unlikely to give up Niger toehold as threat of ECOWAS military action looms
CAR mercenary becomes first African to die in Ukraine conflict
Overcoming insecurity to unlock the Central African Republic’s mineral riches
Rain, rain go away
Africa, Asia most people living in extreme poverty
10 African countries to experience world’s fastest population growth to 2100
EM winners and losers from the global green transformation
Russia seeks to expand its nuclear energy dominance with new international projects
EBRD warns of risks for emerging markets pursuing industrial policies
Russia blocks UN Security Council resolution on Sudan humanitarian crisis
G20 summit wraps up with a joint statement strong on sentiment, but short on specifics
SDS storms fed by sand and dust equal in weight to 350 Great Pyramids of Giza, says UNCCD
Southern Africa has 'enormous' potential for green hydrogen production, study finds
Malaysia seeks BRICS membership
Kazakhstan has no plans to join BRICS, says Astana
Sri Lanka to apply for BRICS membership
From oil to minerals: Gabon’s ambitious mining transition
How France is losing Africa
Guinea grants final approvals to Rio Tinto for $11.6bn Simandou iron-ore project
Mixing with the running stars at Kenya’s Home of Champions high altitude training camp
Kenya’s untapped mineral wealth holds the promise of economic transformation
US adds 17 Liberian-flagged bulk carriers and oil tankers to Russian sanctions-busting blacklist
Panama and Liberia vying for largest maritime registry
Force majeure at Libya’s Zawiya Refinery threatens exports and oil expansion plans
Russia, facing loss of Syrian base for Africa operations, seen turning to war-torn Sudan or divided Libya
Libya’s mineral riches: unlocking a future beyond oil
Russia funding war in Ukraine via illegal gold mining in Africa – WGC report
Ukraine claims it was behind massacre of Wagner Group mercenaries in Mali
Can Morocco's phosphate wealth put it at the centre of the global battery supply chain?
Hajj aftermath: deaths, disappearances and detentions spark investigations across world
Sri Lanka's LTL Holdings targets African power sector
Russia's nuclear diplomacy binding emerging markets to the Kremlin
Can Niger's military junta seize the country's uranium opportunity?
Disaster season: heat waves sweep the world – in charts and maps
AI will be a major source of GHGs by 2030, says Morgan Stanley
Niger and beyond: Francophone credit delivers coup de grâce
EBRD 2023: Bank to expand into the whole of Africa plus Iraq
Global coal trade approaches its peak
The world has passed peak per capital CO₂ emissions, but overall emissions are still rising
Trump threatens BRICS with tariffs if they dump the dollar
SITREP: Middle East rapidly destabilised by a week of missile strikes
Colombian mercenaries trapped in Sudan’s conflict
Air France diverts Red Sea flights after crew spots 'luminous object'
COMMENT: Tunisia on the brink of collapse
Tunisian President Kais Saied re-elected for second term
WHO declares "global public health emergency" owing to mpox outbreak in Central Africa, new virus strain
Climate crisis-driven global food security deteriorated between 2019 and 2022 and is even affecting the US
Cost of repairing Syria’s power infrastructure put at $40bn by electricity minister
Indian banks' profitability to moderate in FY26
Former chief of the Bank of Japan sees more rate hikes on the horizon
Is China ready for Trump’s tariff threats?
Google enters India’s carbon removal market with biochar deal with Varaha
Renewables Down Under, and under the Long White Cloud
CHN Energy connects Rudong Solar Hydrogen-Storage project to the grid in China
Microsoft to invest $3bn in India
International highway tears through Bosnia’s rural heartlands
Japan’s ramen shops face crisis as rising costs push more to bankruptcy
Seoul-listed DoubleU acquires 60% stake in Turkey’s Paxie Games for $27mn
Singapore’s PacificLight Power embarks on $735mn hydrogen power plant project
India's Competition Commission approves major steel industry acquisition
Trump vows to block Nippon Steel's $14bn bid for US Steel
HESS: Mongolia’s unique success story between rock and a hard place at risk
Mongolia copper-gold discovery hailed for “globally significant” prospects
Powerful earthquakes hit Taiwan - TSMC evacuates employees
Starlink satellite internet has more than 30,000 users in Iran
COMMENT: Gulf states court Russia but stop short of strategic shift
Bahrain's security chief meets Syrian commander amid diplomatic push
Bahrain and Iran to begin talks on normalising relations
Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Kuwait set to offer Russians visa-free entry
COMMENT: Iran holds its breath as Trump’s second coming nears
Iran seeks to expand nuclear power cooperation with Russia's Rosatom
UPDATED: Hamas military leader thanks Iran, vows resistance will continue
Iraq seeks Iran-backed militia disarmament in new push
Iraq's London moment marks its post-Saddam era's coming of age
Iraq, BP to sign major Kirkuk fields deal worth over $27bn
Israeli military seizes large weapons cache in Syrian territory
Israel and Hamas reach agreement on hostage deal, Trump confirms
Damascus International Airport resumes operations
Turkey, Syria tandem could mean piped Qatari gas for Europe and a supercharged Middle East clean energy transition
Qatar-Turkey-Europe gas pipeline ambition could be back on following fall of Assad
As jubilant Syrian refugees in Turkey celebrate Assad downfall, analysts wonder what comes next in power vacuum
Syrian foreign ministry urges Kuwait to reopen embassy in Damascus
Kuwait greenlights tax deal with Iraq to prevent double taxation
Iran demands 'equal footing' with Kuwaiti and Saudi plans to drill for gas in Gulf
French president in Lebanon to meet the country's new leaders
ICJ's Nawaf Salam appointed as Lebanon's new Prime Minister
Lebanon faces a new phase: will Hezbollah surrender its weapons to the state?
Lebanon ends two-year void with military chief Aoun as president
US winds down Guantanamo Bay with removal of Yemenis to Oman
So you want to get on the right side of Donald Trump? Try gift-wrapping a hotel
ANALYSIS: Regional escalation on the table following Israeli strike on Iran
Syria seeks Qatar support in rebuilding effort as ministers meet in Doha
Qatar joins regional powers in Damascus diplomatic outreach
Yemen launches missile at Israeli base amid US-UK airstrikes escalation
Iran's former foreign minister proposes new MWADA regional security framework
COMMENT: A call for stability and inclusion as Syria grapples with an extremist government challenge
New Syrian Administration seeks to rejoin Arab League
Dubai's Damac plans $20bn US data centre investment
Argentina announces ambitious nuclear programme linked to AI development
Latin America set for tepid growth as Trump tariff threat looms, ECLAC says
Latin America urged to boost tax take and private investment to close development gap
IMF: Breaking Latin America’s cycle of low growth and violence
COMMENT: Trump’s White House picks signal rocky start with Latin America
Latin America trapped in low growth cycle, ECLAC warns
Bolivian President Arce declares "coca is not cocaine" as country expands coca industry
Bolivia's lithium deals with Russia, China raise sovereignty concerns as state bears heavy risks
Bolivian ex-president Evo Morales faces formal charges of human trafficking
Brazil court blocks Bolsonaro from attending Trump inauguration over flight risk fears
Geothermal energy poised for major global expansion, says IEA chief Fatih Birol
Iranian influx to Venezuela via Colombia triggers regional security fears
Cuba prisoner release after terror delisting marks last-gasp reset in US ties before Trump return
Brutal gang violence over failed voodoo spell claims nearly 200 lives in Haiti's capital
EU and Mexico strike historic trade pact
Amazon Web Services to invest $5bn in Mexico digital hub push
Mexico unveils curbs on Chinese imports in overture to Trump
Russian exiles flee war and persecution, seeking refuge in Mexico
Trump vows to “take back” Panama Canal in inauguration speech
Panama rejects Trump's military threats over canal control
Paraguay stands firm with Taiwan amid growing Chinese pressure
Peruvian president's secret plastic surgery ignites scandal
Murder exposes secret prostitution ring in Peruvian Congress
BRICS bank chief touts Uruguay membership in Montevideo talks
Italian aid worker held without charge in Venezuela for two months
Venezuela’s Maduro sworn in for third term as international criticism mounts
Venezuelan opposition leader Machado released after brief detention
Bangladesh’s BNP urges interim government to expedite elections
Bangladesh revokes former Prime Minister Hasina’s passport
Bangladesh explores tank purchase from Turkey as India receives request for Hasina’s extradition
Controversial 10-GW hydropower project in Tibet greenlit by Beijing
China's coast guard deployment raises tensions in South China Sea, Philippines protests
Balancing growth and sustainability: Southeast Asia’s energy dilemma
US imposes preliminary duties on Southeast Asian solar imports
Angkor Archaeological Park attracts nearly 700,000 foreign tourists in nine months
China, US strive for balance as vice president Han Zheng meets key figures in Washington
The Philippines takes a stand against China's maritime aggression in the South China Sea
Japan establishes diplomatic mission to NATO as ties to Russia, China deteriorate
Peru's APEC summit exposes trade tug-of-war between Beijing and Washington
Rising gold ETF inflows set to drive global bullion prices
Russian exports of diamonds to Hong Kong up 18-fold in 5M24
Gazli Gas responds to reports on Uzbekistan project, refutes any suggestion sanctioned individuals are involved
Trump Tantrum impact on the Indian rupee expected to be temporary
Navigating the four year long India-China border standoff
Russia backs Vietnam's bid to join BRICS
Indonesia joins BRICS despite concerns over potential Trump threats
Hiroshima invites Trump to mark 80th anniversary of atomic bombing
China signals willingness for dialogue with US as Beijing accepts invite to attend Trump’s inauguration
BCPG to invest $945mn in power projects, prioritising clean energy
Hundreds of children killed or injured in Myanmar in 2024: UNICEF
Myanmar junta to allow observers for controversial 2025 election amid ongoing conflict
Over 120 dead as powerful tremor hits Tibet
Nepal floods - death toll rises to 209
Kolkata hospital rape and murder case sparks international outcry, raises questions
South Asia hit by floods and landslides after heavy rainfall
North Korea issues warning in response to air drills with B-1B bombers
North Korea escalates tensions with ballistic missile launch ahead of Trump's inauguration
Prosecution, overthrow or death – how most South Korean presidents have met their political end
Russia’s arms exports slump, Kremlin preparing for possible war with Nato
Security personnel dead as Imran Khan’s supporters breach Islamabad lockdown
Pakistan could quit TAPI as India now “extremely lukewarm” on gas pipeline project, says report
Papua New Guinea tribal conflict leaves 30 dead amid gold mine dispute
Trump to give thumbs up on expedited arms supply to Taiwan
Extreme weather surges in 2024
Kamala Harris to visit Singapore, Bahrain and Germany on final vice-presidential overseas trip
South Korea’s central bank freezes rates amid weakened economy and political turmoil
Sri Lanka’s merchandise exports in October up 18.22%
Taiwan's first execution in five years sparks human rights backlash
BRICS expands membership, adding Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand
German Prosecutors Confirm Termination of Money Laundering Investigation Against Alisher Usmanov
Comments by President of the Russian Fertilizers Producers Association Andrey Guryev on bilateral meeting between Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin
PhosAgro/UNESCO/IUPAC green chemistry research grants awarded for the 8th time to world's best young scientists
PhosAgro Tops RAEX ESG Ranking
Download the pdf version
Try PRO
This article is part of a series looking at the impact of the fall in oil prices on the region's biggest oil producers. The previous articles were on Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan.
"There are no real checks and balances on [Russian President Vladimir] Putin's power. There is no well-developed strategy. The government is weak and can't make decisions. Putin has been reactive, but he needs to react faster and faster. Crimea was a gift to the people and the euphoria lasted a year. Then there was Syria. It's like Viagra: it works for a while, but you have to keep taking more and more."
That, in a nutshell, is what is wrong with Russia today, professor of political economy Nikolai Petrov from Moscow's Higher Economic School tells bne IntelliNews in an exclusive interview.
The headlines might be focused on the impact of $30 a barrel oil price and the knock-on effects, but for the Kremlin, the fall in oil is only secondary to its main problem: how will it maintain control of the Duma in September's general election if people's lives are getting visibly worse?
For Putin the showdown with the West over first Ukraine and now Syria has been a political gift. His sky-high popularity over the last decade and half was predicated on the political stability and economic prosperity he brought. When he took over from an ailing and increasingly erratic Boris Yeltsin, Russia's economy was worth just under $200bn; at its peak in 2013 it was worth $2.1 trillion. The wealth of the country didn't just grow on Putin's watch, it decupled.
Today, the economy is worth a lot less, approximately $1.2 trillion according to VTB Capital's calculations, and if Russia puts in another year of recession it could drop below $1 trillion. This should have translated into faltering support for Putin and his proxy in the Duma, United Russia, but he masterfully played on national sentiment to actually increase his popularity to record highs. The Russian superpower is back on the international stage – or so it seems to the Russians.
But the heady effects of these big geopolitical plays wear off very quickly, argues Petrov, who believes that Putin is a master tactician but lacks a long-term strategy.
"The costs are increasing all the time. Syria was a positive result for Putin, but now he can’t get anything else positive out of it. He needs to capitalise on that deal. The benefit is fixed, but the costs are rising constantly. And the capital he made has already all been spent," says the economist, who specialises in Russia's regional politics.
In the past, Putin simply bought off the voting public. In the run-up to his re-election in 2012, he increased pensions by 50%. In the run-up to this one, and before the next presidential vote in 2018, he has effectively reduced pensions again by capping indexation at 4% – way below the 13% rate of inflation. And the bad economic news keeps getting worse. Real incomes fell by just under 10%, the economy contracted by 3.7% and the ruble is in the mire, lurching between RUB75 and RUB80 to the dollar, whereas it was in the low RUB30s just over a year ago.
Nationalism gave Putin's popularity a boost, but the underlying reality of the situation is already starting to eat into his, and more importantly, the government's support. Putin's personal approval rating fell from 85% to 82% in the last week of January, according to the independent pollster the Levada Center. However, the number of respondents that think "Russia is going the wrong way" has jumped, as has the number that worry Russia is on course for another financial crisis like that of 1998 – now almost half the country.
"On the eve of the elections, the Kremlin is in an even worse position than it was ahead of the previous elections five years ago," says Petrov, whose institute is on Moscow's slushy Ilinka Ulitsa, right next door to the Ministry of Finance and a stone's throw from Red Square, the heart of Russian power.
Party politics
United Russia only just scraped a majority in the 2011 elections after winning a constitutional majority in the previous polls in 2006 with a 66% share. In fact, it didn't earn either of these votes, as in both cases it was shown after the fact that the count was rigged to deliver on both these key thresholds (there were visible spikes at the round numbers consistent with election officials rounding up vote counts in favour of the ruling party). In 2006, the population took the vote-fixing lying down. They did not in December 2011; Moscow was rocked by the first mass protests in a decade with over 100,000 taking to the streets. Those protests have changed everything.
It is already obvious that left to its own devices United Russia has little chance of winning 50% at the polls this September. So the Kremlin is getting ready to hedge its bets.
In January, a new law quietly slipped through the Duma, passing in all three readings at once that allows for the creation of more parties. On the face of it, making it easier to register a political party is a good thing. But in Putin's Russia the only really efficient political machine is the Kremlin itself, and it intends to set up its own parties to cater to the electorate's slowly growing desire for more plurality at the ballot box.
"It's like the Kremlin is producing an election 'menu'," says Petrov. "If they see that pensions are going to be a problem, then they will create a party of pensioners; if they think the problem is going to be with [small business], then they will create a pro-business party."
And a new pro-business party has already appeared: on January 25, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said business ombudsman Boris Titov was forming a conservative party to represent the interests of business in the upcoming elections. Peskov didn't explain why it was the job of the presidential press spokesman to break the news that a nominally independent political party was about to take to the public stage – but then he didn't have to.
"The Kremlin needs more parties, as it will create more competition. The problem they have now is if a party becomes unpopular like United Russia, what can you do?" asks Petrov. "But if you have lots of parties, then you can just switch from one to the other if things go badly."
It's a hybrid system similar to the way the banking and gas sector are organised: the state sets up two competing state-controlled entities to introduce competition and improve efficiency, but ultimately both entities (Gazprom/Rosneft, Sberbank/VTB) are controlled by the state.
Titov has long represented the interests of business as the head of the independent business association Delovaya Rossiya (Working Russia). In late 2012, as bne IntelliNews reported in its cover story interview with Titov, "Russia's corruption tsar", he was charged with leading the fight against graft.
This is actually the Kremlin's third stab at setting up a controllable business party. Oligarch and close Putin confidant Mikhail Prokhorov set up the identical Party of Civic Platform that was supposed to run in the 2011 election, until the whole experience went to his head and he started to have real opinions about what needs to be done. The party was quickly shut down and Prokhorov withdrew from political life.
The only other parties in Russia are: Vladimir Zhirinovsky's Liberal Democratic Party of Russia (LDPR), which was co-opted by the Kremlin long ago; the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (KPRF), which is a spent force and also Kremlin friendly these days; and A Just Russia, which was set up by a stooge but is a real, if small protest vote in the Duma. The same thing happened with Rodina, which was set up to appeal to the middle classes but had too many ideas of its own and was merged with the pensioners' party to form A Just Russia in 2006.
The "true" opposition, headed by figures like Alexei Navalny, has failed to form a united front and even if they did, it is highly unlikely they would be able to surmount the bureaucratic barriers the Kremlin is bound to put in their way and actually field candidates in a national vote.
As if to emphasis the point, on Febuary 1, veteran Russian liberal opposition party Yabloko turned down a proposal from the PARNAS opposition party that they merge to compile a single list of Duma election candidates. This left both parties small and unlikely to pass the 5% of votes threshold needed to enter parliament.
Regional games
The new parties will play an important role in the election, but the Kremlin's main effort will be to get the regional elites to deliver votes on election day. And here too Putin has a serious problem.
In the 2011 elections, the regions delivered just enough votes to allow United Russia to take just over 50%. But according to a bne IntelliNews drill down into the results by region, two-thirds of Russia's regions gave United Russia less than 50%. It was only because of the extremely high count in the "loyal" regions (Chechnya under Ramzan Kadyrov claimed close to 100% support) that the party squeaked into office and promptly took control of all the important Duma committees that make policy.
A handful of other regions, mostly in the Caucasus, turned in close to 100% support for the party. Like the Moscow mayoral election, the extraordinarily strong support for United Russia in only six regions was enough to ensure its majority.
Despite the image of Putin's monolithic control over Russia's polity, his grip on power in the regions is actually limited: the spread between the highest vote for United Russia in Chechnya of 99.5% and the lowest in the Yaroslavl Oblast of 29% in 2011 was extremely wide.
The Kremlin is now terrified of sparking another round of mass protests and, as the victory of an opposition Communist candidate in last year's regional vote in Irkutsk showed, it would rather lose the vote than blatantly fix the result. The result must have sent shockwaves through the administration.
The biggest change in the way things are run from 2011 is that the Kremlin will be relying heavily on the regional elites to deliver victories – and in doing so Putin will hand them real power in the process. "They have decided it is easier to win single mandate seats in the regions than to deliver a mass win using partly lists, but this means you need a strong local candidate," says Petrov.
Petrov argues that Putin significantly weakened his hand by getting rid of local elections and replacing governors with political appointees. During his term as president, Dmitry Medvedev tried to reverse this decision, but the project went nowhere. The upshot is poor regional management and political discontent in the regions, which only weakens Putin's position further.
"This has led to a military-style election in the regions," says Petrov. "The Kremlin is not interested in the legitimacy or hearing other voices. But it also means that the regional elite will find it harder to deliver victories for the Kremlin in their regions."
The competition to find strong regional players to stand for the Kremlin will start soon and there will be a lot of horse-trading involved. The regional elites (the administration bosses together with the local oligarchs) will demand some quid pro quo and will want to see their own representatives in the Duma. In the past, the centre has just poured money into the regions.
"The centre is still able to fix all the [regional] problems manually – by giving out money [to regions in trouble]," of which there are many, says Petrov. "There is no reason to expect serious protests in the next couple of years. But the mistake [former finance minister Alexei] Kudrin and others are making is to assume that if there is enough money, there will be no crisis."
Petrov argues that all this means progress, as power is devolving to an extent from the centre. But he also worries that Putin's system is inherently unstable and is failing to keep up with the demands of the times. "The system has become more sophisticated, but the danger is whether it has enough time to modernise in this way or whether it will collapse before," says Petrov.
Plan K
All this only takes us up to the winter of 2016. What happens then? Petrov worries that while Putin has run circles around the EU and US in his various geopolitical clashes (the advantage of having a weak democracy is he is not slowed down by checks and balances), he has no long-term plan.
Or maybe he does. The need for deep structural reforms is painfully obvious, but Putin has made it clear that he is going to sacrifice Russia's economic health for his geopolitical goals by refusing to cut military spending, which now makes up a third of the budget. Financial wellbeing and social support should be the top priority areas of national policy, according to respondents of a recent poll by the Levada Center, while democracy, reforms and freedom of speech are seen as less important.
Petrov says that Putin is distracted by the game of geopolitics he is currently playing with the West, but has a "Plan K" in mind: bring Kudrin back as prime minister and unleash him on the economy. Kudrin quit his job over a clash with then president Medvedev, insisting that military spending should be cut. But Putin has kept him close ever since.
"Kudrin wants it and is clearly preparing for it. His civil society institute has been travelling the country and drilling down into the nitty-gritty of Russia's economic problems. But no one knows for sure what Putin really has in mind and that is the root of the problem," Petrov says.
Speculation over Kudrin's imminent return continues to swirl, but Putin is unlikely to start on such a radical plan until he has capitalised on his investments into the Ukrainian and Syrian conflicts with an improved position for Russia on the international stage. He will also have to wait until the September autumn elections are passed, says Petrov.
In the meantime, Putin is running the risk of an implosion, as Russian politics are entirely centred on himself. To highlight the point, Petrov asks: what would happen if Putin were killed in a car crash tomorrow? "No one has any idea of what would happen next. There is no one on the stage who is an obvious candidate to take over," says Petrov. "It would be chaos."
Register here to continue reading this article and 8 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Google Captcha Failed!
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription