NEO: Why pick-up points for online orders are gaining popularity vs. home delivery
First sighting of Belarusian jailed opposition leader Viktor Babariko in two years
Russia, Belarus make first cross-border digital financial asset transactions
Belarus tests new BUK missile system as a low-key arms race in Eastern Europe gathers momentum
MOSCOW BLOG: Russia's looming credit crisis
#BREAKING: Czechia wraps up work on pipeline expansion to end reliance on Russian oil
COMMENT: Gulf states court Russia but stop short of strategic shift
New US oil sanctions, attack on Turkstream shake up global energy markets
Russia’s war machine fed by free-flowing exports of Uzbek “guncotton” pulp, say reports
airBaltic CEO and IPO under pressure after flight cancellations
COMMENT: The EU’s Green Deal is a “policy disaster”
Damage of key infrastructure on the seabed of the Baltic raises security concerns, calls for Nato involvement
Telia willing to sell its Latvian operations back to government if price is right
Czech industry falls by 2.7% y/y in November in another disappointing performance
EBRD delivers 26% expansion in investments in 2024, commits record €16.6bn across economies
Czech police request parliament strip far-right leader of immunity
China's Xinzhi creates 900 jobs with €120mn investment in Hungary
Hungary's industry mired in recession in November as October bounce proves one-off
German electricity prices highest in Europe, 70% above the European average, with Hungary's the lowest
US sanctions key Orban ally for corruption
Poland says Netanyahu can come for Auschwitz anniversary despite ICC warrant
EU presidency passes from Putin-whispering Hungary to hawkish Poland
Polish manufacturers go deeper in downturn mode in December
#UPDATED: Slovakia’s populist PM Fico faces no-confidence motion
Slovakia’s Fico steps up anti-Ukraine rhetoric over gas cut-off
Absent Slovak premier traced to luxury hotel in Vietnam
Slovakia faces cut-off of Russian gas pipeline supplies
The EU Council calls for a European geothermal action plan
FDI in Emerging Europe hit by geopolitical uncertainty and German slowdown
Slovenia sets up emergency alert system after devastating floods
BALKAN BLOG: Trump’s annexation remarks risk reigniting Balkan border disputes
Italy eyes restart of Albania migrant processing scheme despite legal hurdles
Albania imposes one-year TikTok ban
Athens conditions support for Albania’s EU accession on protection for Greek minority
BALKAN BLOG: Mass shootings become a powerful impetus for protest in the Western Balkans
BALKAN BLOG: What Grenell’s return means for US diplomacy in the Balkans
Inspired by Trump, Bulgarian far-right leader wants to annex North Macedonia and parts of Ukraine
Kazakhstan’s KazMunayGas reportedly bids for Lukoil’s Bulgarian asset
Greeks cross border for cheap clothes, food and fuel after Bulgaria enters Schengen zone
Koncar fuels record surge on Zagreb Stock Exchange
Croatia’s incumbent President Milanovic wins landslide re-election
President Milanovic poised for landslide re-election in Croatia
Pro-Kremlin disinformation campaign reportedly targeted Croatian presidential election
Nato chief warns of destabilisation risk around Kosovo's February general election
Kosovo’s authorities shut down Serbian tax office in North Mitrovica
BALKAN BLOG: Giving free energy to Transnistria could thwart Russia’s plans for Moldova
Energy crisis in Moldova’s separatist Transnistria escalates
Moldova's breakaway Transnistria region opts for self-imposed energy blockade
Thousands of Montenegrins demand resignation of ministers after Cetinje shooting
Gunman kills 12 in Montenegro mass shooting
North Macedonia's central bank lowers key interest rate by 0.25 pp to 5.55%
Net FDI in Romania dips in 2024
Romania’s political deadlock deepens as nationalists rise
Putin-Trump summit planned — but where will it happen?
Serbia plans to buy out Russian stake in NIS following US sanctions
TurkStream is now the only route for Russian gas to Europe
Turkish issuers sell record $33bn of eurobonds in 2024
Russia’s Rosatom plans legal action over non-delivery of Siemens Energy parts for Turkey’s first nuclear plant
34 companies raise 60bn lira via Istanbul IPOs in 2024
PANNIER: Tajikistan, Taliban tone down the hostile rhetoric
Central Asia emerges as new e-commerce hub
Growing Islamic finance in Central Asia to unlock GCC investment
CSTO states express serious concern over terrorist threat in Afghanistan
Armenian prime minister discusses EU membership plans with European Council president
OUTLOOK: Caucasus 2025
Armenia approves EU membership bid further straining ties with Russia
Former Karabakh leader Ruben Vardanyan faces life in prison
Gas exports to Europe to boost Azerbaijan's growth over next decade
Azerbaijan’s Aliyev sees potential alignment with Trump, criticises Biden administration
Georgians still resisting: the view from Rustaveli
Georgian Dream MPs attack Georgian citizen in Abu Dhabi restaurant
Georgia’s once vibrant theatres fall silent
Kazakh services conclude 2024 with marginal drop in activity, PMI shows
OUTLOOK: Kazakhstan 2025
Central Asian leaders look to expand mutual trade
China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan railway officially launched, but sidetracked at least until summer
Smog back with a vengeance in Ulaanbaatar
EBRD warns of risks for emerging markets pursuing industrial policies
Hit indirectly by sanctions, Mongolia struggles to find workarounds
PANNIER: Why the Turkmenistan, Iran gas “friendship” is back on
OUTLOOK Uzbekistan 2025
Sanctioned Russian cargo ship sinks in Mediterranean after explosion
Russia's budget oil breakeven price world’s second lowest as oil revenues recover
Southeast European countries look to Algeria to diversify energy supplies
Slovenia turns back to Algerian gas after flirtation with Russian supplies
IEA: Access to energy improving worldwide, driven by renewables
The hurricane season in 2024 was weird
Global warming will increase crop yields in Global North, but reduce them in Global South
Hundreds of millions on verge of starvation, billions more undernourished as Climate Crisis droughts take their toll
Global access to energy starts to fall for the first time in a decade, says IEA
Saudi Arabia hosts kingdom's first Africa summit, to boost ties, promote stability
Putin at 2023 Africa-Russia summit: Wiping debts, donating grain and boosting co-operation
Botswana throws the diamond industry a lifeline
Nelson Mandela worried about natural diamonds, Leonardo di Caprio defended them, makers of lab-grown stones demonise them
Botswana’s 2,492-carat diamond discovery is golden opportunity to replicate legendary Jonker diamond's global legacy
Kamikaze marketing: how the natural diamond industry could have reacted to the lab-grown threat
Russia’s Rosatom to support nuclear projects across Africa at AEW2024
JPMorgan, Chase and HSBC reportedly unwittingly processed payments for Wagner warlord Prigozhin
Burkina Faso the latest African country to enter nuclear power plant construction talks with Russia
IMF: China’s slowdown will hit sub-Saharan growth
Moscow unlikely to give up Niger toehold as threat of ECOWAS military action looms
Overcoming insecurity to unlock the Central African Republic’s mineral riches
Russia funding war in Ukraine via illegal gold mining in Africa – WGC report
Rain, rain go away
Africa, Asia most people living in extreme poverty
10 African countries to experience world’s fastest population growth to 2100
EM winners and losers from the global green transformation
Russia seeks to expand its nuclear energy dominance with new international projects
Russia blocks UN Security Council resolution on Sudan humanitarian crisis
G20 summit wraps up with a joint statement strong on sentiment, but short on specifics
SDS storms fed by sand and dust equal in weight to 350 Great Pyramids of Giza, says UNCCD
Southern Africa has 'enormous' potential for green hydrogen production, study finds
Malaysia seeks BRICS membership
Kazakhstan has no plans to join BRICS, says Astana
Sri Lanka to apply for BRICS membership
From oil to minerals: Gabon’s ambitious mining transition
How France is losing Africa
Guinea grants final approvals to Rio Tinto for $11.6bn Simandou iron-ore project
Kenya’s untapped mineral wealth holds the promise of economic transformation
US adds 17 Liberian-flagged bulk carriers and oil tankers to Russian sanctions-busting blacklist
Panama and Liberia vying for largest maritime registry
Force majeure at Libya’s Zawiya Refinery threatens exports and oil expansion plans
Russia, facing loss of Syrian base for Africa operations, seen turning to war-torn Sudan or divided Libya
Libya’s mineral riches: unlocking a future beyond oil
Ukraine claims it was behind massacre of Wagner Group mercenaries in Mali
Can Morocco's phosphate wealth put it at the centre of the global battery supply chain?
Hajj aftermath: deaths, disappearances and detentions spark investigations across world
Sri Lanka's LTL Holdings targets African power sector
Russia's nuclear diplomacy binding emerging markets to the Kremlin
Can Niger's military junta seize the country's uranium opportunity?
Disaster season: heat waves sweep the world – in charts and maps
AI will be a major source of GHGs by 2030, says Morgan Stanley
Niger and beyond: Francophone credit delivers coup de grâce
EBRD 2023: Bank to expand into the whole of Africa plus Iraq
Global coal trade approaches its peak
The world has passed peak per capital CO₂ emissions, but overall emissions are still rising
Trump threatens BRICS with tariffs if they dump the dollar
SITREP: Middle East rapidly destabilised by a week of missile strikes
Colombian mercenaries trapped in Sudan’s conflict
Air France diverts Red Sea flights after crew spots 'luminous object'
COMMENT: Tunisia on the brink of collapse
Tunisian President Kais Saied re-elected for second term
WHO declares "global public health emergency" owing to mpox outbreak in Central Africa, new virus strain
Climate crisis-driven global food security deteriorated between 2019 and 2022 and is even affecting the US
Cost of repairing Syria’s power infrastructure put at $40bn by electricity minister
Indian banks' profitability to moderate in FY26
Former chief of the Bank of Japan sees more rate hikes on the horizon
Is China ready for Trump’s tariff threats?
Renewables Down Under, and under the Long White Cloud
CHN Energy connects Rudong Solar Hydrogen-Storage project to the grid in China
Microsoft to invest $3bn in India
International highway tears through Bosnia’s rural heartlands
Japan’s ramen shops face crisis as rising costs push more to bankruptcy
Seoul-listed DoubleU acquires 60% stake in Turkey’s Paxie Games for $27mn
Singapore’s PacificLight Power embarks on $735mn hydrogen power plant project
India's Competition Commission approves major steel industry acquisition
Trump vows to block Nippon Steel's $14bn bid for US Steel
HESS: Mongolia’s unique success story between rock and a hard place at risk
Mongolia copper-gold discovery hailed for “globally significant” prospects
Starlink satellite internet has more than 30,000 users in Iran
Russia sells stakes in Kazakhstan uranium JVs to China
Bahrain's security chief meets Syrian commander amid diplomatic push
Bahrain and Iran to begin talks on normalising relations
Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Kuwait set to offer Russians visa-free entry
Iranian influx to Venezuela via Colombia triggers regional security fears
Iran calls nuclear talks with E3 serious, constructive
OUTLOOK Iran 2025
Iranian carrier plans European routes as sanctions ease
UK crime agency helps Iraqi forces arrest three Kurds over people smuggling
Britain signs landmark Iraq deal including migrant returns accord
UK and Iraq sign GBP12.3bn partnership deal
Israel and Hamas near hostage deal as mediators report breakthrough
Biden imposes chip export controls on Israel in final days
Iran reveals underground missile base used in Israel strikes
Damascus International Airport resumes operations
Turkey, Syria tandem could mean piped Qatari gas for Europe and a supercharged Middle East clean energy transition
Qatar-Turkey-Europe gas pipeline ambition could be back on following fall of Assad
As jubilant Syrian refugees in Turkey celebrate Assad downfall, analysts wonder what comes next in power vacuum
Syrian foreign ministry urges Kuwait to reopen embassy in Damascus
Kuwait greenlights tax deal with Iraq to prevent double taxation
Iran demands 'equal footing' with Kuwaiti and Saudi plans to drill for gas in Gulf
ICJ's Nawaf Salam appointed as Lebanon's new Prime Minister
Lebanon faces a new phase: will Hezbollah surrender its weapons to the state?
Lebanon ends two-year void with military chief Aoun as president
Lebanon seizes alleged Iranian cash transfer to Hezbollah from diplomat
US winds down Guantanamo Bay with removal of Yemenis to Oman
So you want to get on the right side of Donald Trump? Try gift-wrapping a hotel
ANALYSIS: Regional escalation on the table following Israeli strike on Iran
Syria seeks Qatar support in rebuilding effort as ministers meet in Doha
Qatar joins regional powers in Damascus diplomatic outreach
Yemen launches missile at Israeli base amid US-UK airstrikes escalation
Iran's former foreign minister proposes new MWADA regional security framework
Germany ignored multiple warnings by Saudi Arabia before Magdeburg attack
New Syrian leadership pledges reforms in talks with Italy
Risk of Israel-Turkey war in new Syria assessed by Israeli government commission
Dubai's Damac plans $20bn US data centre investment
Israel launches biggest strike in Yemen, killing 40 people
Argentina announces ambitious nuclear programme linked to AI development
Latin America set for tepid growth as Trump tariff threat looms, ECLAC says
Latin America urged to boost tax take and private investment to close development gap
IMF: Breaking Latin America’s cycle of low growth and violence
COMMENT: Trump’s White House picks signal rocky start with Latin America
Latin America trapped in low growth cycle, ECLAC warns
Bolivian President Arce declares "coca is not cocaine" as country expands coca industry
Bolivia's lithium deals with Russia, China raise sovereignty concerns as state bears heavy risks
Bolivian ex-president Evo Morales faces formal charges of human trafficking
Geothermal energy poised for major global expansion, says IEA chief Fatih Birol
US-Cuba rum war spills over as Biden law stirs Havana Club row
Brutal gang violence over failed voodoo spell claims nearly 200 lives in Haiti's capital
Russian exiles flee war and persecution, seeking refuge in Mexico
Mexico's new leader enjoys strong public backing despite security woes
Mexican cartel boss who created fearsome Zetas returns to face justice after US deportation
Panama rejects Trump's military threats over canal control
Paraguay stands firm with Taiwan amid growing Chinese pressure
Murder exposes secret prostitution ring in Peruvian Congress
BRICS bank chief touts Uruguay membership in Montevideo talks
Venezuela’s Maduro sworn in for third term as international criticism mounts
Venezuelan opposition leader Machado released after brief detention
Venezuela detains US citizens and foreign "mercenaries" ahead of Maduro inauguration
Bangladesh’s BNP urges interim government to expedite elections
Bangladesh revokes former Prime Minister Hasina’s passport
Bangladesh explores tank purchase from Turkey as India receives request for Hasina’s extradition
Controversial 10-GW hydropower project in Tibet greenlit by Beijing
China's coast guard deployment raises tensions in South China Sea, Philippines protests
Balancing growth and sustainability: Southeast Asia’s energy dilemma
US imposes preliminary duties on Southeast Asian solar imports
Angkor Archaeological Park attracts nearly 700,000 foreign tourists in nine months
Peru's APEC summit exposes trade tug-of-war between Beijing and Washington
Rising gold ETF inflows set to drive global bullion prices
Russian exports of diamonds to Hong Kong up 18-fold in 5M24
Gazli Gas responds to reports on Uzbekistan project, refutes any suggestion sanctioned individuals are involved
Navigating the four year long India-China border standoff
US to remove barriers to nuclear collaboration with India
Indonesia joins BRICS despite concerns over potential Trump threats
BRICS expands membership, adding Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand
North Korea escalates tensions with ballistic missile launch ahead of Trump's inauguration
Japan's wage surge fuels expectations of January BOJ rate hike
Japan’s flu outbreak hits record high amid winter surge
BCPG to invest $945mn in power projects, prioritising clean energy
Hundreds of children killed or injured in Myanmar in 2024: UNICEF
Myanmar junta to allow observers for controversial 2025 election amid ongoing conflict
Over 120 dead as powerful tremor hits Tibet
Nepal floods - death toll rises to 209
Kolkata hospital rape and murder case sparks international outcry, raises questions
South Asia hit by floods and landslides after heavy rainfall
Prosecution, overthrow or death – how most South Korean presidents have met their political end
North Korea claims breakthrough with new hypersonic missile test
North Korea’s missile support to Russia raises alarms at UN
Russia’s arms exports slump, Kremlin preparing for possible war with Nato
Security personnel dead as Imran Khan’s supporters breach Islamabad lockdown
Pakistan could quit TAPI as India now “extremely lukewarm” on gas pipeline project, says report
Papua New Guinea tribal conflict leaves 30 dead amid gold mine dispute
Extreme weather surges in 2024
ING: India is likely to remain the region's fastest growing country in 2025
Asia’s shipbuilding renaissance: record orders and rising prices
Kamala Harris to visit Singapore, Bahrain and Germany on final vice-presidential overseas trip
UPDATE: South Korean investigators enter presidential compound to arrest Yoon Suk Yeol
Impeached South Korean president's aide pleads to halt detention efforts as political tensions escalate
Sri Lanka’s merchandise exports in October up 18.22%
A surge in influenza cases, rare COVID symptom hit Taiwan as Lunar New Year approaches
China denies involvement in Taiwan's undersea cable damage amid rising tensions
Pompeo eyes continuity in US-Taiwan policy under Trump’s second term
BYD sales soar signalling a shift in global EV market dynamics
German Prosecutors Confirm Termination of Money Laundering Investigation Against Alisher Usmanov
Comments by President of the Russian Fertilizers Producers Association Andrey Guryev on bilateral meeting between Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin
PhosAgro/UNESCO/IUPAC green chemistry research grants awarded for the 8th time to world's best young scientists
PhosAgro Tops RAEX ESG Ranking
Download the pdf version
Try PRO
Russia Duma elections are under way but the election is not about re-electing the ruling United Russia Party but more about making sure that jailed anti-corruption activist and opposition politician Alexei Navalny’s smart voting project is a total failure. The key to achieving that goal has been the Kremlin’s largely successful efforts to cut the opposition off from its main weapon: the internet.
The result of the election is a foregone conclusion. As of late afternoon on the second day of voting on September 18, 90% of the online votes offered in seven regions had been cast and a reported 17% of the physical votes, and preliminary official exit polls give United Russia 48% of the vote, enough to win a clear majority of seats.
Online voting is almost totally opaque and can be used to adjust the results to any outcome the Kremlin wants. It is a more elegant resource than was used in the 2011 vote – the dirtiest election to date that resulted in hundreds of thousands gathering to protest in Bolotnaya Square in Moscow. As bne IntelliNews reported, in that election the Kremlin massively falsified the results in eight key regions, mostly in the Caucasus, to give United Russia up to 100% of the vote so the cumulative nationwide tally was a clear majority for United Russia. The use of online voting means such crude methods as ballot stuffing can be avoided and the final result more elegantly massaged and spread across more regions, making such interference less obvious.
Given it is almost certain that United Russia will be swept to victory, the Kremlin’s goal appears to be to make sure smart voting doesn't overturn a single district and the candidates of the powers that be win every race where there is a smart voting contestant, in an effort to delegitimise the tactic.
“If the Kremlin does have a central focus in this election, it's making sure the @navalny/@leonidvolkov #SmartVoting project fails. And for the most part, the Kremlin is getting its way,” Sam Greene, a professor of politics at King's College London and the director of King's College Russia Institute, said in a tweet. “But everything we've seen thus far points to an equally important priority for Team Putin: Making sure Team Navalny fails. Losing even a single "safe" seat to a #SmartVoting candidates would feel unthinkable. The Kremlin needs SmartVoting to be an abject failure.”
Blocking the Navalny App
The Kremlin has pulled out all the stops to crush the smart voting initiative and the state information and media regulator Roskomnadzor has made frantic efforts to close Navalny’s operation down.
The campaign started with declaring Navalny’s organisation extremist in June, so anyone co-operating with the project would face criminal charges and a long jail sentence.
The next step was to block Navalny's smart voting site on September 6 and then remove the Navalny app from both Google and Apple app stores.
At the same time, VPN networks that allow users to sidestep Kremlin blocks on sites were also largely disabled, starting in June. The result is that while much of the content was still accessible in Russia it has become increasingly difficult to reach. The technology that enabled Roskomnadzor to block VPNs was first rolled out in the spring, when it was added to operators' servers as part of the new “sovereign RuNet” legislation that forces companies to bring their user information onshore.
The regulator conducted the first high-profile tests of this technology in the spring, when it decided to successfully slow Twitter down, but did not block it completely.
The final step has been to try to kill the list of smart candidates to vote for, which Team Navalny released on social media 48 hours ahead of the vote – a point where the Kremlin can no longer remove any of the names from the election roll – which was hosted on Google Docs.
Both Google and Apple rolled over and complied with the order and removed the Navalny app. Reportedly, rather than threatening the company with legal action, Google’s local staff in Russia were instead threatened with arrest to get their company to comply.
Late into the game on the second day of voting tech wunderkind Pavel Durov also agreed to disable bots on the Telegram message service that provide information to subscribers about who to vote for in the elections.
Justifying the decision, Durov explained in a post on his Telegram channel that the network will observe Russia’s “election silence” during the voting process. “We consider this practice to be legitimate and call on Telegram users to respect it. Beginning at midnight, Moscow time [September 18], we plan to restrict the functionality of bots associated with election campaigning.”
The opposition leaders must be very disappointed, as Telegram has been the backbone of protests against many authoritarian regimes like Belarus and Iran, and in those countries it defied government orders to turn off the service, which is widely used by protest organisers.
Unlike these other protests, the Kremlin has been highly successful at muzzling the online resources that have so successfully been used against regimes elsewhere.
Part of this is due to the Kremlin specifically targeting the Navalny app and its lists. There was speculation that the Kremlin would simply attempt to turn the internet off, as happened in the Minsk mass demonstrations last summer, or close sites like Twitter and Facebook.
“We don't seem – yet – to be seeing what many observers most feared: a massive, Belarus-style internet blackout. Of course, a lot of the censorship was done well before the elections kicked off. But there could have been more,” says Greene. “There had also been at least some expectation that access to Facebook, Twitter and YouTube would be severely limited or blocked altogether. Thus far (and there's two days to go), none of that has happened. The Kremlin seems satisfied that its combination of centralised anti-Navalny disruption and decentralised "proactive compliance" by local election managers will do the trick.”
Apple and Google under pressure
Late in the evening of September 8 Roskomnadzor began testing blocking of public DNS services Google and Cloudflare, which protect web portals, The Bell reports.
“The tests lasted only an hour, and we learned about them only thanks to the vigilance of IT experts. After that, it was reported that Roskomnadzor recommended state-owned companies to switch to Russian DNS servers or NSDI (National Domain Name System) rather than use foreign ones,” The Bell said in a report. “Why all this is needed is anyone's guess, but most likely the matter is in the services for encrypting DNS queries, including the DoH service mentioned in the regulator's reports. With its help, you can hide from the provider the address of the site to which the user is trying to enter. This is exactly what Roskomnadzor is now trying to fight: encryption prevents operators from seeing the user's request and, if necessary, blocking it. The problem is that blocking public DNS will inevitably lead to the disabling of an unpredictable set of different services and, importantly, IoT devices, so Roskomnadzor will probably use this tool only in emergency cases.”
Roskomnadzor also took out the VPN services in June, including the popular VyprVPN and Opera VPN, which were banned. The last six, which included ExpressVPN, NordVPN and IPVanish VPN, all ranked among the world's best VPNs, were banned in Russia in early September, reports the Bell.
While taking down websites and preventing Russian users by-passing the bans by going overseas via a VPN proved relatively easy to organise; taking out the Navalny app was a lot more difficult.
On August 19 Roskomnadzor demanded that Apple and Google remove the application from their stores due to the fact that it is associated with Navalny’s Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK) that was declared an extremist organisation, on a par with a terrorist group.
The representatives of both companies were summoned to the Federation Council and after resisting both finally caved in as voting got underway on September 17. The Navalny application with built-in Smart Voting was in both the tech companies’ stores, but was removed as the polls opened. Those that had already downloaded it can keep it and it still works, but it is no longer available to anyone else.
The last challenge was to get the smart voting lists hosted on Google Docs deleted. The Kremlin has been using its commercial leverage over the international internet giants to bully them into compliance. Internet penetration has exploded as Russians have embraced the new economy technology and as bne IntelliNews has reported, e-commerce is booming, given a boost last by the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. Russia is now the largest online market and long since has had more people online than Germany, the most populous country in Europe after Russia. Even though Google is trailing behind Russia’s own Yandex, the most valuable tech company on the Continent, Russia is already too big a market to ignore. For Apple, Russia is already the biggest market in Europe too.
On the eve of the elections, reports started coming in that Google Docs was no longer accessible to some Russian users as Roskomnadzor began testing its ability to shut the service down just after Team Navalny released the smart voting lists. Roskomnadzor quickly denied blocking the service, saying questions about the failure of the service should go to Google. It is not clear what happened but industry sources talking to The Bell report that Roskomnadzor was testing its ability to block the service. But rather than carry out a damaging and indiscriminate shutdown of the widely used service, Roskomnadzor managed to persuade Google to cut access to the lists on the grounds they are associated with an “extremist” organisation and that refusing carries severe criminal penalties for non-compliance.
Will smart voting fail?
With another day of voting ahead it appears that the Kremlin has the upper hand. Belarus' President Alexander Lukashenko was made to look a fool for attacking social media services that were used so effectively against him. As bne IntelliNews reported in the feature “Nexta: Belarus’ revolution by committee”, the informal leaders of the opposition could control crowds in real time using the Nexta Telegram channel and the authorities were powerless to prevent it. In Russia the Kremlin seems to have been largely successful in locking down Team Navalny’s best effort to disseminate the crucial smart voting lists to the Russian electorate. The lists have been published and read by millions of people but by the first day of voting it was already difficult to find the lists online.
“The underlying data for the system has now made its way to various servers – including Wikipedia – but centralised, easy to find and read distribution of Smart Voting guidance has effectively been disrupted,” Greene tweeted.
Team Navalny has presented alternative candidates for the State Duma elections in all 225 single-mandate constituencies, conceding that the Kremlin has control over the remaining 225 party list constituencies that will mostly be won by United Russia. Usually United Russia does not field a candidate in some of these constituencies to allow the parties from the systemic opposition to win enough seats to clear the 5% threshold and get into the Duma, although as a sign of the Kremlin’s nervousness it has conceded fewer of these seats this year than in the last elections.
Nearly two thirds of the smart voting recommendations are from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (KPRF), which ironically has been the big winner from the Team Navalny campaign, despite the fact that the KPRF itself rejects Navalny and his initiative.
However, while smart voting has become a major headache for the Kremlin, it is estimated to change the course of voting by about 5% in each race and that is not enough to deliver more than a minority of upsets. In 2020, the tactic was most successful in the regional elections, where 19 candidates out of 27 supported by smart voting entered the Tomsk City Duma, and 14 out of 50 in Novosibirsk. However, the main effect of the tactic is to de-legitimise the Kremlin further and force it to cheat more blatantly, which will undermine the Kremlin’s authority further. If the Kremlin pushes its efforts to fix the election too far and ignores the protest vote completely, it runs the risk of sparking mass demonstrations again, like those that followed the 2011 elections.
Register here to continue reading this article and 8 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Google Captcha Failed!
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription