Belarus tests new BUK missile system as a low-key arms race in Eastern Europe gathers momentum
CSTO states express serious concern over terrorist threat in Afghanistan
Armenia refuses to host Eurasian Economic Union summit
COMMENT: Trump 2.0 could be a blessing for Belarus
PANNIER: Why the Turkmenistan, Iran gas “friendship” is back on
Russia’s CBR keeps key rate at 21% under pressure
Russia’s arms exports slump, Kremlin preparing for possible war with Nato
North Korea’s missile support to Russia raises alarms at UN
Ukraine invasion was ‘spontaneous’ and unplanned, Putin claims
Bulgaria’s interim PM Glavchev refuses to sign 10-year military support deal with Ukraine
North Korean troops face heavy losses in Russia-Ukraine War as conflict intensifies
Telia willing to sell its Latvian operations back to government if price is right
The EU Council calls for a European geothermal action plan
FDI in Emerging Europe hit by geopolitical uncertainty and German slowdown
IMF: The 2004 EU enlargement was a success story built on deep reform efforts
Czech National Bank keeps interest rates at 4%
Czech EPH signs agreement with Italian Enel to buy its stake in Slovenske Elektrarne
Hungary grants political asylum to fugitive former PiS minister
Hungarian households have joint lowest consumption levels in EU
Polish industrial production disappoints in November as output falls 1.5% y/y
Polish producer price deflation eases further in November
Slovak, Hungarian, Austrian and Italian groups sign declaration backing continued gas transit through Ukraine
Slovenia sets up emergency alert system after devastating floods
Athens conditions support for Albania’s EU accession on protection for Greek minority
EU Council says enlargement is a "geo-strategic investment in peace"
Bureks vs. Big Macs
BALKAN BLOG: What Grenell’s return means for US diplomacy in the Balkans
International highway tears through Bosnia’s rural heartlands
Russia reaps harvest of chaos in nearby democracies
Croatian Bosqar Invest acquires bakery Mlinar in €100mn deal
TikTok says it has stepped up moderation ahead of Croatian presidential election
Kosovo's population down 12% since 2011
Kosovo’s president slams EU’s “unfair” treatment
Moldova's economy shrinks by 1.9% y/y in Q3
Serbia faces backlash over controversial foreign agents bill
North Macedonia's central bank lowers key interest rate by 0.25 pp to 5.55%
North Macedonia’s ex-deputy PM Grubi reportedly flees to Kosovo to avoid detention in corruption case
Formation of ruling coalition in Romania faces deadlock as Social Democrats suspend talks
Turkey, Syria tandem could mean piped Qatari gas for Europe and a supercharged Middle East clean energy transition
Syrian-Kurdish SDF’s fighters from outside Syria will leave if Turkey agrees ceasefire, says commander
Istanbul cruise port debt “re-restructured”, banks take 49% stake
Growing Islamic finance in Central Asia to unlock GCC investment
INTERVIEW: Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank financing Central Asia’s green future
Award seen as Nobel Prize for human rights won by Kabul women’s rights activist and jailed Tajik lawyer
Corruption probe launched into Armenian satellite project
EBRD warns of risks for emerging markets pursuing industrial policies
Several top Armenian officials resign amid political shake-up
Azerbaijan trades barbs with French and US diplomats in online "Twiplomacy"
Azerbaijan’s Aliyev lines up with Russia and Trump, admits Georgia interference
Trial of seven AbzasMedia journalists begins in Baku
COMMENT: Could Iran open new fronts against Israel and Azerbaijan?
PROFILE: Georgian President Salome Zourabichvili
World Bank approves $350mn as Tajikistan bids to fund completion of $6.3bn Rogun mega hydro project
Russia sells stakes in Kazakhstan uranium JVs to China
Freedom Holding Corp brings FIDE world rapid & blitz chess championships to Wall Street
Adylbek Kasymaliev appointed new chief of Kyrgyzstan’s cabinet ministers, predecessor dismissed amid tax corruption scandal
Decades-old Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan border dispute could be over
Kyrgyzstan: MPs seem willing to give police a free hand
Hit indirectly by sanctions, Mongolia struggles to find workarounds
HESS: Mongolia’s unique success story between rock and a hard place at risk
Mongolia copper-gold discovery hailed for “globally significant” prospects
Tajikistan: Officials announce discovery of major rare earth deposits
Tajikistan: Rogun Dam is a white elephant in the making – report
COP29: Central Asian states losing arable land
Uzbek national arrested in Moscow bombing that killed Russian chemical defence chief Kirillov
Uzbekistan’s Moscow embassy “clarifying” details on man detained after scooter-bomb assassination of Russian general
Russia's budget oil breakeven price world’s second lowest as oil revenues recover
Southeast European countries look to Algeria to diversify energy supplies
Slovenia turns back to Algerian gas after flirtation with Russian supplies
“Silent demise” of world’s vast rangelands threatens food supply of billions, warns UNCCD report
IEA: Access to energy improving worldwide, driven by renewables
The hurricane season in 2024 was weird
Global warming will increase crop yields in Global North, but reduce them in Global South
Hundreds of millions on verge of starvation, billions more undernourished as Climate Crisis droughts take their toll
Global access to energy starts to fall for the first time in a decade, says IEA
Saudi Arabia hosts kingdom's first Africa summit, to boost ties, promote stability
Putin at 2023 Africa-Russia summit: Wiping debts, donating grain and boosting co-operation
EBRD 2023: Bank to expand into the whole of Africa plus Iraq
Botswana throws the diamond industry a lifeline
Nelson Mandela worried about natural diamonds, Leonardo di Caprio defended them, makers of lab-grown stones demonise them
Botswana’s 2,492-carat diamond discovery is golden opportunity to replicate legendary Jonker diamond's global legacy
Kamikaze marketing: how the natural diamond industry could have reacted to the lab-grown threat
Russia’s Rosatom to support nuclear projects across Africa at AEW2024
JPMorgan, Chase and HSBC reportedly unwittingly processed payments for Wagner warlord Prigozhin
Burkina Faso the latest African country to enter nuclear power plant construction talks with Russia
IMF: China’s slowdown will hit sub-Saharan growth
Moscow unlikely to give up Niger toehold as threat of ECOWAS military action looms
Overcoming insecurity to unlock the Central African Republic’s mineral riches
Russia funding war in Ukraine via illegal gold mining in Africa – WGC report
Rain, rain go away
Africa, Asia most people living in extreme poverty
10 African countries to experience world’s fastest population growth to 2100
EM winners and losers from the global green transformation
Russia blocks UN Security Council resolution on Sudan humanitarian crisis
G20 summit wraps up with a joint statement strong on sentiment, but short on specifics
Malaysia seeks BRICS membership
SDS storms fed by sand and dust equal in weight to 350 Great Pyramids of Giza, says UNCCD
Southern Africa has 'enormous' potential for green hydrogen production, study finds
Kazakhstan has no plans to join BRICS, says Astana
Sri Lanka to apply for BRICS membership
How France is losing Africa
Gabon coup attempt after the re-election of President Ali Bongo
Guinea grants final approvals to Rio Tinto for $11.6bn Simandou iron-ore project
Kenya’s untapped mineral wealth holds the promise of economic transformation
US adds 17 Liberian-flagged bulk carriers and oil tankers to Russian sanctions-busting blacklist
Panama and Liberia vying for largest maritime registry
Force majeure at Libya’s Zawiya Refinery threatens exports and oil expansion plans
Russia, facing loss of Syrian base for Africa operations, seen turning to war-torn Sudan or divided Libya
Libya’s mineral riches: unlocking a future beyond oil
Ukraine claims it was behind massacre of Wagner Group mercenaries in Mali
Can Morocco's phosphate wealth put it at the centre of the global battery supply chain?
Hajj aftermath: deaths, disappearances and detentions spark investigations across world
Sri Lanka's LTL Holdings targets African power sector
Russia's nuclear diplomacy binding emerging markets to the Kremlin
Can Niger's military junta seize the country's uranium opportunity?
Disaster season: heat waves sweep the world – in charts and maps
AI will be a major source of GHGs by 2030, says Morgan Stanley
Niger and beyond: Francophone credit delivers coup de grâce
The world has passed peak per capital CO₂ emissions, but overall emissions are still rising
Trump threatens BRICS with tariffs if they dump the dollar
SITREP: Middle East rapidly destabilised by a week of missile strikes
Colombian mercenaries trapped in Sudan’s conflict
Air France diverts Red Sea flights after crew spots 'luminous object'
COMMENT: Tunisia on the brink of collapse
Tunisian President Kais Saied re-elected for second term
WHO declares "global public health emergency" owing to mpox outbreak in Central Africa, new virus strain
Climate crisis-driven global food security deteriorated between 2019 and 2022 and is even affecting the US
South Korea’s won slides as martial law crisis sparks market turmoil
China unveils $71bn swap facility to revitalise flagging economy
Fukushima's forgotten victims as Japan shifts back to nuclear power
Balancing growth and sustainability: Southeast Asia’s energy dilemma
India’s second-largest clean energy company ReNew plans to go private
India's Competition Commission approves major steel industry acquisition
Trump vows to block Nippon Steel's $14bn bid for US Steel
China dismisses Trump's tariff threat, warns of 'no winners' in trade war
Iraq blocks IMDb website over 'immoral content' claims
Display unveils groundbreaking 50% stretchable screen: a game-changer for fashion and mobility
South Korean users flock to YouTube and Instagram as local platforms struggle
Bahrain and Iran to begin talks on normalising relations
Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Kuwait set to offer Russians visa-free entry
Jaw-dropping discovery: 450,000-year-old tooth unearthed in Iran
China's COMAC eyes Saudi Arabia as launchpad for international expansion
Iranian ambassador claims US sets conditions on Syrian-Iranian relations
Syria's new leader al-Sharaa declares "end of Iranian project"
Iran to add 500MW solar capacity by year-end, targets 4GW expansion
ISTANBUL BLOG: After “conquering” Damascus, Erdogan turns his eye to the Kurds
Israeli settlers from extremist sect cross into Lebanon, IDF confirms
Trump keeping Erdogan “on his toes” over unfolding Syria events, says analyst
Iran's Khamenei gives Syria speech in front of women-only audience
Qatar-Turkey-Europe gas pipeline ambition could be back on following fall of Assad
As jubilant Syrian refugees in Turkey celebrate Assad downfall, analysts wonder what comes next in power vacuum
Erdogan sets Damascus as final target for “rebels” advancing in Syria
Kuwait greenlights tax deal with Iraq to prevent double taxation
Iran demands 'equal footing' with Kuwaiti and Saudi plans to drill for gas in Gulf
Middle East power grid struggles as demand hits record high
Iraq braces for severe heatwave with temperatures to reach 49C
How Assad turned Syria into a narco-state
So you want to get on the right side of Donald Trump? Try gift-wrapping a hotel
ANALYSIS: Regional escalation on the table following Israeli strike on Iran
Sea of Oman oil terminal boosts export resilience amid tensions with Israel
Israel establishes “winter military positions” in Syrian territory
New Syrian authorities accuse Israel of unlawful attack on country
Israel attacks more than 250 military targets in Syria in 48 hours
COMMENT: A stable Syria could become a major energy hub
Saudi Arabia extracts lithium from oilfield runoff, plans commercial pilot
Saudi Arabia wins 2034 World Cup bid, beating Australia
UPDATED: Syria's former president Assad arrives in Moscow
Israel launches biggest strike in Yemen, killing 40 people
TEHRAN BLOG: Pezeshkian's dilemma over Haniyeh's assassination
Iranian foreign ministry condemns Haniyeh's assassination in Tehran
Reactions to the killing of Haniyeh in Tehran
Latin America set for tepid growth as Trump tariff threat looms, ECLAC says
Latin America urged to boost tax take and private investment to close development gap
IMF: Breaking Latin America’s cycle of low growth and violence
COMMENT: Trump’s White House picks signal rocky start with Latin America
Latin America trapped in low growth cycle, ECLAC warns
Bolivian ex-president Evo Morales faces formal charges of human trafficking
Geothermal energy poised for major global expansion, says IEA chief Fatih Birol
US-Cuba rum war spills over as Biden law stirs Havana Club row
Brutal gang violence over failed voodoo spell claims nearly 200 lives in Haiti's capital
Mexican cartel boss who created fearsome Zetas returns to face justice after US deportation
Paraguay stands firm with Taiwan amid growing Chinese pressure
Murder exposes secret prostitution ring in Peruvian Congress
Protests in Bangladesh escalate, demanding president leave office
Bangladesh tribunal issues arrest warrant against ousted PM Sheikh Hasina
World Bank says Bangladesh GDP growth to shrink in FY25
US imposes preliminary duties on Southeast Asian solar imports
COMMENT: From Globalisation to “slowbalisation” as FDIs decline on trade and geopolitical woes
Angkor Archaeological Park attracts nearly 700,000 foreign tourists in nine months
Blinken warns Taiwan crisis could trigger global economic turmoil
Iran boosts oil, gas output amid US crackdown on sales
Peru's APEC summit exposes trade tug-of-war between Beijing and Washington
Rising gold ETF inflows set to drive global bullion prices
Russian exports of diamonds to Hong Kong up 18-fold in 5M24
Gazli Gas responds to reports on Uzbekistan project, refutes any suggestion sanctioned individuals are involved
Valuation questions raised over Blackstone's $2.1bn IPO of India’s International Gemmologist Institute
INTERVIEW: Jeet Chandan, co-founder of Indian investment platform BizDateUp
Where does nuclear power-use stand in post-COP29 Asia?
Boldly brewing where no one has brewed before: Japanese sake to be made in space
South Korean president impeached, Constitutional Court to sit December 16
Japan plans tax hike to fund $280bn military buildup
BCPG to invest $945mn in power projects, prioritising clean energy
Malaysia’s industrial growth slows in October following mixed sector performance
Myanmar junta to allow observers for controversial 2025 election amid ongoing conflict
Nepal floods - death toll rises to 209
Kolkata hospital rape and murder case sparks international outcry, raises questions
South Asia hit by floods and landslides after heavy rainfall
Russian pivot to the Global South includes unscrupulous army recruiting practices
North Korean troops suffer casualties in Ukraine conflict
South Korea intensifies military drills to bolster defences against North Korean drone threat
Security personnel dead as Imran Khan’s supporters breach Islamabad lockdown
Pakistan could quit TAPI as India now “extremely lukewarm” on gas pipeline project, says report
Papua New Guinea tribal conflict leaves 30 dead amid gold mine dispute
Thousands evacuated as Mt. Kanlaon erupts, threatening more explosive activity
South Korea's acting president rejects six controversial bills amid growing tensions
Korean won dips to crisis levels amid US rate cuts and market volatility
Sri Lanka’s merchandise exports in October up 18.22%
Taiwan boosts defence with advanced Abrams tanks amid rising Chinese tensions
Vietnam faces challenges in meeting carbon emission targets
German Prosecutors Confirm Termination of Money Laundering Investigation Against Alisher Usmanov
Comments by President of the Russian Fertilizers Producers Association Andrey Guryev on bilateral meeting between Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin
PhosAgro/UNESCO/IUPAC green chemistry research grants awarded for the 8th time to world's best young scientists
PhosAgro Tops RAEX ESG Ranking
Download the pdf version
Try PRO
The problems at PrivatBank, co-owned by oligarchs Igor Kolomoisky and Hennady Boholyubov, have forced the Ukrainian government to nationalise the country’s largest commercial bank, putting an end to weeks of speculation over a crisis at the bank resulting from massive insider lending, which was uncovered by bne IntelliNews in November.
“The government believes that this responsible decision... has saved both PrivatBank, as well as the entire banking system,” said a government announcement made at 11:29pm Kyiv time. The decision was taken in coordination with and with support of international financial organisations,” it added.
The move follows growing scrutiny of evidence of the extent of insider lending within PrivatBank, as revealed by a special bne report published on November 1, much of which we represent below.
The loan book of PrivatBank, which was leaked to bne, shows that Ukraine’s largest commercial bank has acted as a little more than a “vacuum cleaner” for the local population’s savings, hoovering up a growing amount and sending it on to obscure shell firms, many owned by related parties or unknown foreign entities. Our investigation revealed that in fact almost all the bank’s largest loans are to such borrowers – some of which are currently being investigated by Ukrainian prosecutors for tax evasion and fraud.
The depth of the problems in PrivatBank’s lending practices was of growing concern to the Ukrainian authorities and the country’s Western donors. Kyiv is desperately trying to contain a financial crisis as the country’s fragile economy – battered by war, decades of misrule and revolution – struggles to stabilise after contracting about 10% last year.
Over the past two and a half years, the country’s regulator, the National Bank of Ukraine (NBU), has attempted a radical overhaul of the banking system, removing the licences of more than 80 lenders, often due to their involvement in money laundering or for not having a transparent ownership structure. Now attention is on the country’s biggest banks like PrivatBank, which require further capitalisation and a reduction in the level of related-party lending – a structural weakness that rating agencies warn is indicative of poor corporate governance and lax lending standards.
Unsurprisingly, the NBU and its determined governor, Valeria Gontareva, are coming under increasingly pressure from a large segment of the old elite, who behind the scenes are trying to undermine the bank’s reformist policies and its independence. On October 10 a number of MPs from four parties submitted a draft law to parliament calling for amendments to the law on the central bank to deprive it of its independence as well as the ouster of Gontareva and her deputies. “As is often the case in Ukraine, it is unclear who is really behind this draft law. It is presented as a populist act, but appears to be initiated by parts of the old elite. They want to return to a weak central bank that happily gives ample refinancing to close friends at the expense of the Ukrainian people,” notes Anders Aslund, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council.
Encouragingly, the heads of 12 of Ukraine’s biggest commercial banks signed a joint letter in support of NBU’s independence and Gontareva, while foreign institutions like the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the EU and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development are also standing behind the bank. The IMF in October called for the government to take measures to resolve the problems at the systemic banks like PrivatBank, including possible nationalisation. But another bailout of Privatbank, which already owes $1.2bn worth of refinancing loans from the central bank, could blow a hole in the country’s budget and its international loan programme.
Privat lessons for the public
PrivatBank is present on every high street across Ukraine, with its branches outnumbering those of the state-owned savings bank Oschadbank. The central bank lists PrivatBank as one of three banks of systemic importance to the country, together with two state banks.
The bank is owned by Kolomoisky and Boholyubov, who together control a sprawling unconsolidated industrial, financial and media empire referred to informally as ‘Privat Group’, while also financing political parties. Of the two longstanding partners, sources say the bank belongs to Kolomoisky’s respective sphere of influence, who according to the website is the largest shareholder with almost 50%.
In 2014, Kolomoisky earned international accolades when as governor of his native region of Dnipropetrovsk he rallied eastern Ukraine against the rising Russian-backed separatism, financing volunteer fighters out of his own pocket. But in 2015 he clashed with Ukraine’s new president, Petro Poroshenko, over control of large state energy companies. Poroshenko and Kolomoisky later buried the hatchet, with Kolomoisky’s 1+1 TV channel since then providing benign coverage of the president, who is himself the subject of mounting revelations about his murky business interests.
But the situation at PrivatBank poses a new challenge to Ukraine’s stability, as the country’s largest bank by assets has aggressively ratcheted up its share of Ukraine’s retail deposits past the 37% mark, with UAH148bn (€5.2bn) in individual deposits out of a total of UAH409bn in the system, according to central bank statistics in July.
Repaying depositors at PrivatBank in the case of an insolvency would very quickly exhaust the country’s deposit guarantee scheme. In Ukraine, the state insures retail deposits up to a sum of UAH200,000 (€7,041), incentivising depositors to prioritise high interest rates over concerns about stability when choosing banks. Thus the depositors continue to flock to PrivatBank, even after the collapse of fourth largest bank Delta Bank in 2015, which had also targeted the retail deposit market.
But depositors might stop rushing to PrivatBank if they had a chance to examine in detail the lender’s book of assets over UAH10mn (around €350,000) for July 2016, which has been shared with bne IntelliNews.
The €6bn question
According to the loan book leaked to bne IntelliNews, there is only a handful of identifiable large-scale borrowers in the bank’s roughly €6bn loan business, with the rest being no-name Ukrainian shell firms or offshores vehicles.
The largest borrower with an identifiable business is the Borivazh grain terminal in Odesa region, which holds just over UAH3.6bn in loans. The agricultural machinery distributor Novofarm holds UAH1.9bn. Optimus Plyus, part of the Optimus agricultural holding also has UAH1.9bn. Fuel concern Ukrtatnafta holds UAH550mn, TV channel 1+1 Production holds UAH626mn. Air carrier Dniproavia, chemicals firm Dniproazot and oil refiner Galichina have smaller loans. These are all businesses linked to the PrivatBank shareholders.
Some further entities are more obscure, but contain the “Privat” brand in the name, indicating they also belong to the group: Perspektiva Privat Development (UAH700mn) and Privat DPFG (UAH1.1bn), and Privatbud, Privatofis and Privatlizing with far smaller loans.
Counter-intuitively, many of the well-known Privat Group corporate entities involved in the metallurgy, aviation and chemicals sectors do not feature on the PrivatBank book of loans worth over UAH10mn. The book contains only one major individual borrower, a Dnipropetrovsk businessman who is an ally of the PrivatBank shareholders. He holds a loan of UAH500,000.
This means that loans made to identifiable Privat Group entities totals around UAH10bn, which comprises just 5% of total gross loans worth UAH203.5bn, according to the NBU. This figure is not far off PrivatBank’s own calculation using what it says is the methodology provided by the NBU. “As of September 28, 2016, the related-party loans of the bank accounted for just 4.71% of the total loan portfolio," the bank said in a statement dated October 5.
In the same statement, the bank said under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) the level of loans issued to related parties accounted for just 17.7% of the bank’s total loan portfolio at the end of 2015 – a calculation it claims is confirmed by a PwC audit. But the central bank puts PrivatBank related-party loans at 38.5%, acknowledges PrivatBank spokesperson Oleh Serga. “This is the result of a change in definition of related parties,” he explains.
The problem is that the documents leaked to bne IntelliNews show that apart from these identifiable Privat Group structures, hardly any other borrower on the loan book is a recognisable corporate brand, easily identifiable with a real business. For example, only 11 of the around 1,000 borrowers over UAH10mn are joint stock companies, even though most large businesses in Ukraine are incorporated as joint stock firms as a legacy of the post-Soviet voucher privatisation.
Of the 100 largest borrowers (see box below), accounting for UAH94.5bn or 46% of PrivatBank’s gross loans, all but one are limited liability firms. Most are registered in Kharkiv and Dnipropetrovsk, excluding the offshores, although PrivatBank has a dense national branch network. Hardly a single company has a recognisable brand name. Some of these are owned by Ukrainian individuals, but most are owned by offshore structures. Another 8% of lending, some UAH18bn, goes directly to offshore vehicles.
Hollow in Kharkiv
For example, a group of freshly incorporated Kharkiv-based companies in 2015 and 2016 hold almost $1bn in loans from PrivatBank, according to an analysis of the corporate structure of the borrowers. These loans comprise about 12% of the total PrivatBank loan book.
The loans went to TOV Foburg, Adamant Oil, Alfa Treyd Oil, Avaris, Bryuk Oil, Kapital Oil, Fabricius, Kapital Treyd, Maksi V, Migora, Naftaenerdzhi, Natel, NK Franko, Olimp Oil, Palmira Treyding, Segment Oil, Tais River, Petroil, Taymar, Yuniks Grup, and Zebrina. All these firms were registered in February-May 2015 in residential buildings in the centre of Kharkiv. Amazingly, all have paid up share capital of only UAH1,000 ($40), according to the company register.
Some of the owners of these firms do have a public profile as managers of established companies. Volodymyr Golovko, for example, is the owner of Fabricius, Foburg and Kapital Treyd, according to Ukraine’s corporate register. Golovko is listed in open sources as a former CEO of Zaporozhnefteprodukt and former chairman of Kremenchugnefteprodukt, both fuel trading firms. Serhii Kazarov, owner of Migora, NK Franko, and Yuniks Grup, is a former CEO of Kherson-based agribusiness Optima-Yug. Vyacheslav Plakasov, owner of Petroil, Segment Oil and Kapital Oil, is director of oil trading firm 770 Petroleum. Viktor Shkindel, owner of Zebrina and Naftaenerdzhi, is a former CEO of Dnipropetrovsk Airport.
It is notoriously difficult to pin down exactly what assets belong to the sprawling Privat Group. Ihor Kolomoisky has even denied the existence of any such group in interviews. However, local media reports list as members of the Privat Group these established companies, the former CEOs of which now feature as owners of the 2015-registered Kharkiv shell firms.
The owners could not be contacted for comment on their connections to Privat Group. On paper these men own the borrowers outright as final beneficiaries.
“This information simply does not correspond to reality,” spokesperson Serga says. “The bank’s corporate borrowers have good credit histories, and loans are secured by highly liquid collateral. International surveyors and international auditors regularly appraise the value of our collateral.”
Kolomoisky did not answer his phone when contacted by bne IntelliNews.
Under investigation
Court records show that Ukrainian law enforcement are already scrutinising some of the Kharkiv borrowers’ dealings.
According to a pre-trial police investigation, two of these new firms, Olimp Oil and Adamant Oil, which together hold more than UAH1.5bn (€54mn) in loans from PrivatBank, “belong to one financial-industrial group that sells fuel products via a chain of filling stations under one brand”, it said without naming the group.
The inspection of these two firms has allegedly established that, “the employees of the retail points and the companies systematically falsify financial-accounting documents, including the cash receipts and expenses, leading to large-scale loss of funds to the budget.” The investigation is ongoing.
The investigation also found that these and other Kharkiv-registered PrivatBank borrowers are “de facto headquartered in the Shevchenko district of Dnipro[petrovsk]”, where the PrivatBank headquarters also are located, making it likely that the “one financial-industrial group” referred to by the investigators is the Privat Group.
Another pre-trial investigation lists Kapital Treyd, registered in 2015 in Kharkiv and holding some UAH3bn (€108mn) in loans from PrivatBank, as allegedly connected to massive tax evasion during its sale of oil products to over a hundred different counterparties. NK Franko, Yukon and Segment Oil are also the subjects of pre-trial criminal investigations into tax evasion.
None of these investigations have resulted in any charges being brought yet.
Hoovered up and out
An examination of the bank’s loan books show that the bank lent about €1bn in 2014 to another group of obscure Ukrainian firms, which are now the subject of a criminal investigation into whether these funds were then illegally moved abroad. According to the investigation, these funds may have come from emergency state refinancing loans that were intended to shore up the bank.
According to the pre-trial criminal investigation, in 2014 the bank lent a total of UAH19bn to 42 Ukrainian firms. Control over the 2014 borrowers was exercised via a cluster of 50 offshore firms. PrivatBank lent each of the 42 Ukrainian firms $18mn-73mn, according to the details of the investigation.
The loan book leaked to bne IntelliNews confirms that this lending indeed took place. The 42 firms owe PrivatBank a total of about UAH29bn (13% of total gross loans). The discrepancy in hryvnia sums could be the result from the decline in the value of the hryvnia, since the loans were in dollars. According to the details of the criminal investigation, the loans were to be secured by oil products purchased with the funds.
The recipients of the loans in 2014 then moved the money in turn to six firms registered in the UK and British Virgin Islands, all with accounts at PrivatBank’s Cyprus subsidiary, according to the investigation. The payments comprised 100% advance payment for oil products. But the investigation claimed that no oil products were ever supplied by the non-resident firms to the PrivatBank borrowers, meaning the funds were effectively moved from the loans via the firms out of the country, to accounts at the PrivatBank Cyprus subsidiary.
The bank rejects all the allegations. “In the situation [in 2014] of political crisis and military action in East Ukraine, the bank’s liquidity deteriorated… so there were simply no funds left to ‘siphon off’,” the PrivatBank spokesman said. Regarding stability loans that the central bank provided to PrivatBank in 2014, he explained: “according to the demands of the NBU, these resources were used only to cover withdrawal of deposits by individuals.”
According to the criminal investigation, the 51 offshore vehicles and the 42 suspicious PrivatBank lenders from 2014 are “controlled by the PrivatBank shareholders”.
These 42 suspicious borrowers, however, are only a subset of over 100 Ukrainian shell firms holding large loans from PrivatBank, which are owned by an intertwining network of around 95 offshores, including the 51 named by investigators as controlled by PrivatBank shareholders. These obscure offshore-owned firms holding billions of dollars in loans are registered in Dnipropetrovsk and Kharkiv, and lack websites or any other public profiles.
The total loans held by all the offshore-owned Ukrainian shell firms comprises around 70% of the entire PrivatBank loan portfolio. With 12% held by the 2015 Kharkiv shell companies, and 8% directly by offshore companies, this means that a staggering 90% of PrivatBank loans over UAH10mn are held by local or offshore shell companies.
Fuel for thought
Worries about how much of this lending to obscure shell companies is to related parties is centred on the fact that many of these Ukrainian borrowers play, or have played, a role in Privat Group’s opaque filling station and fuel trading business, according to court records ( list of fuel business firms 2015.pdf), which is also suggested by the frequent use of “Oil” or “Nafta” (Ukrainian for oil) in their names.
Others were listed in July 2015 by an MPs’ investigation into Privat Group’s fuel trading activities, according to an official appeal to the Prosecutor General submitted by the cross-party group of pro-reform MPs ( deputies letter.pdf). The Privat Group controls over 1,500 filling stations across Ukraine, estimates head of research Oleksandr Paraschiy at brokerage Concorde Capital.
According to the MPs’ investigation, the ownership vehicles for the Privat Group fuel business are switched roughly once every six months, from one set of Ukrainian shell firms to another newly created set. The MPs’ letter lists over 100 such firms used to run the filling stations in 2014. At the start of 2015, according to the letter, these firms were all switched and a new set of obscure firms took over the business, in a move they alleged was intended to hide traces.
Leading fuel market analyst Serhiy Kuyon of A95 Consulting agrees with the deputies’ assessment of the modus operandi of Privat Group’s fuel business.
According to Kuyon, the turnover of the business in 2015 was as much as $1.5-2.0bn and working capital was “probably financed” by PrivatBank. Other analysts put turnover lower. Roman Nitsovych, head of the Dixi Group energy consultancy, tips $1bn, while Olesandr Paraschiy, head of research at Concorde Capital, puts it at $0.65bn. The spread of estimates is itself a reflection of the opaque nature of the business.
Boris Timonkin, the former long-serving head of UniCredit’s former subsidiary Ukrsotsbank, who fled Ukraine in 2014 after criminal charges were brought against him, says all this leads him to conclude that PrivatBank does not fulfil the main function of a bank that is commonly understood by everyone: that it should enable the efficient allocation of capital to the parts of the economy in most need of it. Rather, he says, “it is simply a vacuum cleaner” for the population’s savings.
———————————————————————————————————————
Spot the recognisable company: PrivatBank’s top 100 borrowers account for UAH94.5bn (€3.3bn) in loans
TOV Borivazh; TOV Migora; TOV Naftaenerdzhi; TOV ZII Novofarm; TOV Oilstrim; TOV Zebrina; TOV Palmira Treyding; FRANSIANO INVESTMENTS LTD; TOV Petroil; FANDERO LTD; TOV Anabis; TOV Profit; TOV Betenkort; TOV Natel; TOV Optimus Plyus; TOV Tais River; TOV Maksi V; TOV Alfa Treyd Oil; TOV Tekhnispreyd; TOV Labi Treyd; TOV Kapital Treyd; TOV Yuniks Grup; TOV Retonga; TOV Elsis Taym; TOV Paradiz; TOV Impis; TOV Raneya; TOV Metrikom; TOV Elti Treyd; TOV Rapit; TOV Masben; TOV Floreks Industriz; TOV Adzhalik Treyd; TOV Favore; MERITENA INVESTMENTS LTD; TOV Dampir; TOV Adamant Oil; TOV Prado; TOV Taymar; ABENDALE MANAGEMENT CORP.; ROSSYN INVESTING CORP.; TOV Sigmatreyder; CORNESIA CONSULTING LIMITED; TOV Faboris; BILLINGHAM PARTNERS INC; TOV Solmbridzh; TOV Biloris; TOV Tseris; TOV Milorin Ltd; TOB NK Franko; TOV Mirigon; TOV Lansel; TOV Investgrup; TOV Olimp Oil; TOV Reform Plyus; TOV Perspektiva Development; TOV Stels; TOV Tekhservismontazh; TOV Diletra; TOV Transmoloko; TOV Reform Plyus; TOV Versaliya; TOV Viniburg; TOV Vialint; TOV Melitas; TOV Tekhspetsmontazh; TOV Adionis; TOV Megaprom Ltd; TOV Foburg; TOV Intersplav; TsOV Skorzonera; TOV Vesta Kompanii; TOV Polyaris; TOV Avaris; TOV Segment Oil; TOV Fabricius TOV Kartservis Plyus; TOV Tsum; TOV Orbela; TOV Veles Oil; TOV Investgrup; TOV Vialint; TOV Diletra; TOV Maveks Petrol; TOV Donmas; TOV Bias Vektor; TOV Stal; TD KhZhK; Privat DGPG; TOV Mantas; TOV Vihnga; TOV Saltiz; TOV Shelta; TOV Kalari; TOV Mondoro; TOV Svarog Oil; TOV Melitas; TOV Rich Oil; TOV Real Standart
Iranian banks faced massive queues and public frustration on December 17 as widespread branch closures due to gas shortages entered their second week, causing significant disruption to business ... more
The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) has extended a $30mn (€28.5mn) financing package to support the expansion of wastewater infrastructure in Jordan, the bank said in a ... more
The World Bank has to realise that the Rogun mega project “dream of the biggest dam [in the world] will turn into a nightmare for the people and nature in Tajikistan and beyond” and that it ... more
Register here to continue reading this article and 8 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Google Captcha Failed!
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription